We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
THINGS FALL APART
I tuned out the poetry we studied in high school English, which makes me wonder why President-elect Donald Trump’s announcement last week that Matt Gaetz would be his Attorney General made me recall W.B. Yeats’ work, The Second Coming:
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world;
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned…
Trump has vowed to execute every prisoner on federal death row, to expand the federal death penalty to include drug traffickers and migrants who kill U.S. citizens, to use the military to round up and run out immigrants, and to grant all law enforcement officers immunity from criminal prosecution.
Writing in The Watch last week, Radley Balko observed that Trump “of course promised to weaponize federal law enforcement to settle grudges, exact retribution, and protect his interests.”
Congressman Matt Gaetz (R-FL) is slated to serve as Attorney General. Gaetz, whose legal career spans about three years as a junior associate in a small Florida law firm, has never tried a case nor managed an enterprise, but he’s intended to run the Dept of Justice, of which the Bureau of Prisons is a part.
In 2020, Gaetz was accused of child sex trafficking and statutory rape over claims that he paid a 17-year-old high school student for sex. Following an investigation, DOJ decided not to seek charges, concerned that it might not be able to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. Gaetz resigned from the House last week just before the House Ethics Committee was to release a report on the sex charges, alleged drug use and other misconduct.
One DOJ official said of the nomination, “What the f— is happening?!” Another said that Gaetz is the “least qualified person ever nominated for a position in the Department of Justice.”
MSNBC admitted that “in a sense, everybody is unqualified” to serve as Attorney General, because DOJ “is so deep, broad and complex that no one can come in truly prepared for all of it. Nobody comes in knowing everything about tax or antitrust or civil rights or criminal or civil or environmental work. They do not know the intricacies of the work of its many divisions, from the Federal Bureau of Prisons to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.” But, MSNBC argued, AGs need “three qualities: integrity, judgment and independence. With those qualities, you can handle the job… [W]ith Gaetz, you might end up with somebody who is wholly unqualified for the job coupled with somebody who lacks integrity, judgment and independence.”
But why should federal prisoners care? It might be beneficial to have a man who had once been a DOJ target running things.
Don’t count on it. As a state legislator, Gaetz sponsored a bill requiring the Florida governor to sign death warrants for prisoners on death row as soon as their appeals were exhausted. Last July, Gaetz toured El Salvador’s notorious Terrorism Confinement Center where, CNN reported, “convicts and pretrial detainees “spend 23½ hours a day in bleak group cells, eat a bland meatless diet and have just 30 minutes a day for exercise or Bible class.”
“There’s a lot more discipline in this prison than we see in a lot of the prisons in the United States,” Gaetz said at the time. “We think the good ideas in El Salvador actually have legs and can go to other places and help other people be safe and secure and hopeful and prosperous.”
In other transition news, Sen. John Thune (R-SD) will serve as Majority Leader—the person who will control which bills are voted on—in the new Senate, which convenes on Jan 3, 2025. Thune has consistently opposed even modest marijuana reform proposals, once calling legalization a “dangerous path.”
In 2021, Thune acknowledged that marijuana is an “area that’s still evolving, and our country’s views on it are evolving,” adding that “how we deal with it nationally, is still an open question.”
President Biden promised in 2022 that rescheduling marijuana from Schedule I to Schedule III – which could lead to the easing of criminal penalties – would be done by the end of 2024. A DEA hearing on the matter is set for December 4. It’s not clear that final rules can be rolled out before a new and possibly hostile Congress is seated.
Radley Balko – Substack, The “broligarch” threat to criminal justice reform (November 13, 2024)
NBC, Justice Dept. employees stunned at Trump’s ‘insane,’ ‘unbelievable’ choice of Matt Gaetz for attorney general (November 10, 2024)
MSNBC, An attorney general needs 3 qualities to be successful. Matt Gaetz doesn’t even have one. (November 14, 2024)
CNN, Matt Gaetz would oversee US prisons as AG. He thinks El Salvador’s hardline lockups are a model (November 14, 2024)
Marijuana Moment, Every GOP Senate Majority Leader Candidate Opposes Marijuana Legalization (November 12, 2024)
– Thomas L. Root
