Tag Archives: biden

Setting Records, Cleaning Up Messes: The Final Biden Clemencies – Update for January 20, 2025

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

CLEMENCY IS HIS SWAN SONG

swan160314President Joe Biden last Friday broke his own record for the most commutations issued in a single day, shortening the sentences of nearly 2,490 people who – according to the White House – are convicted of nonviolent drug offenses.

The White House has trumpeted that with having granted commutations of over 4,000 over the lifetime of his Administration, Biden has exceeded the previous record set by Barack Obama of 1,715. “With this action, I have now issued more individual pardons and commutations than any president in U.S. history,” Biden crowed in a statement.

A reasonable observer could easily conclude that the President is more interested in making an entry in his Administration’s record book than in righting a historical wrong.

Many of the 2,590 commutations specify a release date for the recipients of February 17. Three are to be released March 18, and additional tranches are to be cut loose in staggered 30-day periods after that. A significant number had their sentences reduced to a specified term of months, meaning that in many cases the inmates still have significant time to serve.

clemency170206Twenty-one of the people commuted last Friday were CARES Act releasees who were omitted from the December 12th commutation list without explanation. Several other CARES Act people whose cases clearly fit the profile of person Biden said he wanted to commute but who were omitted from the December 12th list (and whose offenses are not drug related) still hope for commutation prior to noon today.

The White House announced commutations of two more people and pardons of five – including Jamaican black political activist Marcus Garvey (who died in 1940) – in an announcement yesterday morning.

“This action is an important step toward righting historic wrongs, correcting sentencing disparities, and providing deserving individuals the opportunity to return to their families and communities after spending far too much time behind bars,” Biden said, not mentioning that many of those whose sentences were commuted have been serving time imposed by the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994. Biden was the author, sponsor and principal cheerleader in favor of that legislation.

Some reporter noted as much. One said that with these commutations, Biden “hope[d] to finally correct the historical and devastating blunder of his 1994 Crime Bill that disproportionately affected African Americans.”

pardonme190123This morning,  Biden issued pre-emptive  pardons to people Biden fears will be targeted for retribution by President-elect Trump due to their involvement in his prosecution for the January 6 riot and classified document cases. Those pardoned include Anthony Fauci, General Mark Milley, the staff and members of the January 6th Committee, and Capitol and D.C. Metro police officers who testified before the Committee.

Reason, Biden Has Now Issued Far More Commutations Than Any of His Predecessors (January 15, 2025)

The White House, Clemency Recipient List (January 17, 2025)

The White House, Clemency Recipient List (January 19, 2025)

Washington Informer, Biden Seeks to Correct Historical Wrongs with Commutation of 2,500 Sentences (January 17, 2025)

NBC, Biden sets record for most pardons and commutations with new round of clemency for nonviolent drug offenders (January 17, 2025)

– Thomas L. Root

A Fortnight of Clemencies? – Update for January 14, 2025

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BIDEN’S LAST WEEK (AND TRUMP’S FIRST ONE)

imouttahere250114Although time grows short, the White House has not yet walked back Biden’s promise to issue additional pardons and commutations before he leaves the White House for the last time.

Last week, Truthout.org called on Biden to include in his clemency announcement people serving life sentences under Sentencing Guidelines that have been changed (but the changes not being retroactive). Truthout said, “According to the Sentencing Project, ‘one in seven people in U.S. prisons is serving a life sentence, either life without parole, life with parole or virtual life (50 years or more), totaling 203,865 people’ as of 2021. This is the highest number of people in history — a 66% increase since 2003, the first time the census was taken. Many of these people facing ‘death by incarceration’ were sentenced under guidelines that are no longer used.”

Writing in Forbes, Walter Pavlo last week suggested that consistent with Trump’s desire to trim federal spending, he could double down on First Step Act implementation. Pavlo said, “Trump will likely be frustrated that more has not been done on the First Step Act since his first term in office… The purpose of the First Step Act was to put more minimum-security offenders back home sooner but that has not occurred to the level it could. More prisoners in the community means less reliance on aging facilities that Congress seems unwilling to fund to bring up to acceptable standards.”

creditsign181227Pavlo suggested increased Bureau of Prisons’ use of for-profit halfway houses, besides the network of nonprofit halfway bouses now relied on, and updating the BOP’s security and custody classification system to no longer exclude noncitizens and non-contact sex offenses from camps. As well, he said that the Trump Administration urge Congress to broaden FSA credits to include some of the 68 categories of offenses now prohibited from credits, including some sex offenses, some terrorism charges, threats against government officials and 18 USC § 924(c) gun charges.

Finally, he proposed expanding RDAP eligibility to include those without documented prearrest drug and alcohol use.

Pavlo argued, “The BOP’s challenges are unlikely to be solved through increased funding alone. Instead, the focus should be on fully implementing existing programs like the First Step Act and RDAP, revising outdated policies that hinder efficiency and working with Congress to make targeted legislative adjustments.”

All of this is so, but as a Federal News Network reporter noted a few weeks ago, “I don’t think [the BOP] is high on the Trump team’s agenda, but [it] is a deeply distressed agency.”

Conservative columnist Cal Thomas last week argued that some of the targets of Trump’s desire to save money “are familiar, but one that is never mentioned is the amount of money that could be saved by releasing or not incarcerating nonviolent offenders in the first place… That prison reform has not been on a top 10 list of issues for Republicans is no reason it can’t be added now. Saving money and redeeming a system that no longer benefits the incarcerated or the public is a winning issue.”

Last week, Fox News contributor Jessica Jackson wrote that in 2018, “Trump signed the First Step Act into law, delivering long-overdue reforms that both political parties had failed to achieve at the federal level for decades. It was a landmark moment… Now, as Trump returns to the White House, he has a historic opportunity to finish what he started. Two key reforms he could champion — modernizing federal supervision and expanding second chances — offer a chance to cement his legacy as the leader who transformed America’s approach to justice.”

trumpimback250114However, as of right now, the only criminal justice promise Trump has made is to promise to grant clemency to some or all of the 1,580 people charged or convicted of crimes arising from the January 6, 2021, riot on Capitol Hill.

Truthout.org, Biden Should Go Beyond Commutations for Death Row and Commute Life Sentences Too (January 8, 2025)

Forbes, How Trump Can Shake Up the Bureau of Prisons (January 6, 2025)

Federal News Network, Countdown to Trump II, and what to expect (December 26, 2024)

Washington Times, Prison and sentencing reform: Saving money in an overlooked place (January 6, 2025)

Fox News, Trump defied the odds to win a criminal justice victory in his first term. Could he do it again? (January 6, 2025)

Washington Post, The fate of nearly 1,600 Jan. 6 defendants depends on Donald Trump (January 6, 2025)

– Thomas L. Root

‘Take Your Commutation and Shove It,’ Death Row Inmates Tell Biden – Update for January 7, 2025

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

THANKS BUT NO THANKS

thanksnothanks250107Two federal death row prisoners, who are among the 37 inmates whose death sentences were commuted on December 23 by President Joe Biden, have filed hand-written petitions in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana seeking an injunction against losing their death penalty sentences.

NBC News reported Shannon Agofsky and Len Davis, both housed on death row at USP Terre Haute, filed on December 30, 2024, for injunctive relief to block Biden’s commutation of their death sentences to life in prison without parole.

Shannon said in his petition,

On December 22, 2024, the defendant became aware of the publicity stunt enacted by president Joe Biden, in which he commuted the death sentences of 37 federal prisoners the defendant was part of that group. That defendant never requested commutation the defendant never filed for commutation. The defendant does not want commutation, and refused to sign the paper offered with the commutation.

Len wrote that “there are a host of constitutional violations associated with the executive branch’s attempt to sentence petitioner Davis life sentence without his agreeing to commutation.” Len asked the court to appoint an attorney to represent him and promised to expand on his argument in future filings.

Shannon argued that “[t]o commute his sentence now, while the defendant has active litigation in court, is to strip him of the protection of heightened scrutiny. This constitutes an undue burden, and leaves the defendant in a position of fundamental unfairness, which would decimate his pending appellate procedures.”

The Supreme Court held in Caldwell v. Mississippi that the 8th Amendment imposes a heightened “need for reliability in the determination that death is the appropriate punishment in a specific case.”

Shannon, who maintains his innocence, argued in his petition that he doesn’t want to lose the benefit of that additional scrutiny. Davis, on the other hand, argued that the death sentence draws “attention to the overwhelming misconduct” of the Dept of Justice in his case.

douglassdeathbondage250107Shannon’s and Len’s likelihood of prevailing seems to be a long shot. In Biddle v. Perovich, the Supreme Court 98 years ago pretty clearly held that the president has the authority to commute a death sentence to life and “that the convict’s consent is not required.”

NBC quoted Daniel Kobil, a constitutional law professor at Capital University and a death penalty defense counsel, as explaining that “we impose sentences for the public welfare, the president and governors in states commute sentences for the public welfare.”

Robin Maher, executive director of the nonprofit Death Penalty Information Center, told NBC that the vast majority of inmates on federal death row were grateful for Biden’s decision, “which is constitutionally authorized and absolute.”

Writing in his Sentencing Law and Policy blog, Ohio State University law professor Doug Berman said, “[T]hese efforts to refuse a capital commutation seem likely to help ensure these defendants get more attention for their claims of innocence than many others.  And I have often asserted to students in my sentencing classes that convicted murderers claiming to be wrongfully convicted on death row are likely to get more attention for their claims of innocence than convicted murderers given LWOP.“

NBC, Two death row inmates reject Biden’s commutation of their life sentences (January 6, 2025)

Emergency Petition for Injunctive Relief, Agofsky v. United States, Case No. 2:25-cv-1, Doc. 1 (December 30, 2024)

Emergency Petition for Injunctive Relief, Davis v. United States, Case No. 2:25-cv-2, Doc. 1 (December 30, 2024)

Caldwell v. Mississippi, 472 U.S. 320 (1985)

Biddle v. Perovich, 274 U.S. 480 (1927)

– Thomas L. Root

Death Takes a Christmas Holiday – Update for December 23, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BIDEN CLEANS OUT DEATH ROW SO TRUMP CAN’T

death170602President Biden this morning commuted the death sentences of 92.5% of those on federal death row, converting the sentences of 37 men to life without parole less than a month before Donald J. Trump will return to the Oval Office with a promise to restart legally sanctioned killing.

Only three men, each a mass killer in crimes with special circumstances, will remain on federal death row. Robert D. Bowers, 52, murdered 12 Jewish worshippers at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh. White supremacist Dylann Roof, 30, murdered nine black worshippers at a Charleston, SC, church Charleston, S.C., in 2015; and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, 31, is the survivor (for now) of the two brothers behind the Boston Marathon in 2013 that killed three and injured more than a dozen others. Tsarnaev’s attack was ultimately held to be terrorism-related.

Biden said in a statement, “Today, I am commuting the sentences of 37 of the 40 individuals on federal death row to life sentences without the possibility of parole. These commutations are consistent with the moratorium my Administration has imposed on federal executions, in cases other than terrorism and hate-motivated mass murder.

Biden promised during his 2020 presidential campaign to end the federal death penalty. Although legislation he backed failed to advance in Congress during his administration, Biden directed the Dept of Justice Department to issue a moratorium on federal executions, a stark contrast to Trump’s frenzy of 13 executions in a 6-month period in 2020-2021.

death200623The Bureau of Prisons had to transfer extra personnel from around the system to USP Terre Haute for the executions, a step that became a COVID superspreader event for the federal prison system as the personnel carried the virus back to their home institutions, where it galloped through staff and inmate ranks.

Biden was a longtime advocate for the death penalty, having claimed to have personally written in death as a maximum sentence for a variety of federal crimes in the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994. Even during the moratorium of his current term, DOJ has sought the death penalty in a case where a 34-year-old Uzbekistan native ran down cyclists and joggers with a truck in New York and in the 2022 Buffalo Tops Family Market mass shooting in which an 18-year-old white supremacist murdered 10 black shoppers.

death200330A broad collection of groups and people opposing the death penalty — including civil rights groups, religious organizations, current and former law enforcement officials, ex-prison workers and murder victims’ relatives — had called on Biden to commute the federal death sentences. Nevertheless, the predictable outrage against the commutation began within hours of the announcement, with the New York Post already trumpeting that “Biden commutes death sentences of child killers and mass murderers 2 days before Christmas.”

Biden continues to promise that “[i]n the coming weeks, the President will take additional steps to provide meaningful second chances and continue to review additional pardons and commutations.”

New York Times, Biden Commutes 37 Death Sentences Ahead of Trump’s Plan to Resume Federal Executions (December 23, 2024)

Washington Post, Biden commutes most federal death sentences before Trump takes office (December 23, 2024)

White House, Statement of President Joe Biden (December 23, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Does Backlash on CARES Act Clemency Threatens Further Action? – Update for December 16, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

IS THE BIDEN COMMUTATION WAVE BREAKING ON POLITICAL SHOALS?

As I reported last Thursday, President Biden granted clemency to nearly 1,500 Americans on CARES Act home confinement, people who the White House says “were placed on home confinement during the COVID-19 pandemic and who have successfully reintegrated into their families and communities.”

Biden has promised additional clemencies, and there is no shortage of candidates. But if he anticipated the congratulations of a grateful nation, hw ia probably disappointed.

clemencypitch180716In Pennsylvania, there’s a firestorm over one of those receiving commutation. Michael Conahan was convicted of funneling juvenile defendants to two private, for-profit detention centers in exchange for $2.1 million in kickbacks, a scandal known as “Kids-for-Cash.” That is, he took bribes to send kids to for-profit juvenile prisons with sentences disproportionate to their crimes He pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy and was sentenced in 2011 to 17½ years in prison. He was released to home confinement in Florida under the CARES Act in June 2020.

Sandy Fonzo, a mother who blames her son’s suicide on the emotional toll that being wrongly placed in detention exacted, said, “Conahan’s actions destroyed families, including mine, and my son’s death is a tragic reminder of the consequences of his abuse of power. This pardon feels like an injustice for all of us who still suffer.”

(Conahan was not pardoned. Rather, his sentence was commuted, but his conviction remains intact).

The Pennsylvania governor, Josh Shapiro, also condemned Biden’s decision, telling reporters that his fellow Democrat “got it absolutely wrong”, the Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported.

The Washington Post said:

For Biden, this is another unforced error. More broadly, it raises fresh questions about presidential clemency going too far and whether it should exist at all. There was outrage when former president Donald Trump pardoned allies such as Stephen K. Bannon, Paul Manafort and Charles Kushner, the father of his son-in-law. And there was outrage over Biden pardoning his son Hunter. It could all get even more outrageous if Biden grants preemptive pardons or Trump pardons the January 6 rioters.

Such dubious grants of presidential mercy reinforce a belief that America has a two-tiered justice system where the wealthy and connected fare much better than everyone else — and certainly better than the young people who came before Judges Conahan and Ciavarella in Luzerne County.

takethemoney191015Meanwhile, Biden has been blasted for commuting the sentence of an Illinois CARES Act confinee. A former city official in Illinois who orchestrated the largest municipal embezzlement in state history. Rita Crundwell—with four years to go on a 235-month sentence for fraud, is among the people granted clemency. Crundwell, who was taken out of Dixon, Illinois, city hall in handcuffs back in 2012, stole something like $53 million in city funds during her tenure as city comptroller.. She used the funds to pay for a lavish lifestyle that included raising champion quarter horses and buying a $2 million tour bus, jewels, furs, multiple homes and other trappings. All the while, the City of Dixon struggled to pay for infrastructure and other projects.

Meera Sachdeva, a former Mississippi oncologist, received clemency on her 20-year sentence handed down in 2012 for defrauding Medicare by providing diluted chemotherapy drugs and using old needles at her cancer clinic. Her clinic was said to be so unsanitary that multiple patients were admitted to local hospitals with infections after being treated there. One of Sachdeva’s patients claimed to have contracted HIV because of old needles.

The Washington Free Beacon said in a review of those who received clemency that “many of the recipients were serving sentences for serious crimes.”

Advocacy groups have been calling for a broad range of additional clemency grants, including for people on federal death row and with marijuana convictions. Biden has previously issued blanket pardons for those convicted of minor marijuana-related crimes, but those didn’t make any federal inmates eligible for release, because none of the recipients was in prison.

Rachel Barkow, a New York University law professor and expert on federal clemency, said during an Ohio State clemency conference that commuting the sentences of those on CARES Act home confinement is “low-hanging fruit” because they’re already out of prison.

Barkow expressed concern last Wednesday, the day before the clemency was announced, that CARES Act commutation would be the limit of Biden’s clemency actions. “I’m a little worried that he’s only going to do that and he’s going to try to make it out like that’s some big deal when that’s not a big deal at all. That’s not even the bare minimum,” she said. The hue and cry from both sides of the aisle—focusing on individual cases rather than the common-sense commutation of the entire cohort—could make Biden shy away from anything further.

clemency170206At the same time, the CARES Act clemency was unreasonably opaque, leaving out some people with perfect home confinement records and unremarkable crimes while including people whose offenses – like the kids-for-cash judge and the horse-breeding embezzler – whose commutations sparked predictable media anger. I am aware of at least three people – including a woman who was raped at FCI Dublin but is now on CARES Act home confinement – who were omitted from the list without explanation.

Nevertheless, Biden continues to come under intense pressure from a coalition of civil rights, criminal justice, and religious groups urging him to grant relief to several classes of federal offenders, including the 40 people on federal death row and nonviolent drug offenders.

Last week, faith leaders – including black pastors, Catholics, former corrections officials, civil rights advocates, and current and former prosecutors – called on Biden to commute all federal death row sentences before Trump, who supports capital punishment, takes office.

Others are calling for commutation of sentence for women who suffered sexual abuse at FCI Dublin. “We all just feel so passionately that if Biden can pardon his son, he can definitely grant clemency to survivors of this heinous abuse by federal government employees,” former Dublin prisoner Kendra Drysdale told The Guardian.

jan6riot241216Meanwhile, President-elect Trump told Time Magazine last week that he would offer clemency to most of the rioters who stormed the Capitol. “It’s going to start in the first hour,” he said. “Maybe the first nine minutes.” However, in a filing in a DC sentencing last week, the government warned that a “pardon would not unring the bell of conviction. In fact, quite the opposite. The defendant would first have to accept then pardon, which necessitates a confession of guilt.”

Harrisburg, WBRE-TV, ‘Kids for Cash’ victim reacts after Biden commutes sentence for Pennsylvania judge (December 13, 2024)

Sauk Local News Network, Biden commutes prison sentence of Rita Crundwell, former comptroller who embezzled $53M from city of Dixon (December 12, 2024)

Washington Free Beacon, Drug Lords, Ponzi Schemers, and Corrupt Officials: Meet Joe Biden’s Clemency Recipients (December 13, 2024)

Daily Beast, Mom’s Outrage Over Biden’s Presidential Clemency for Corrupt Kids-for-Cash Judge and Cohort (December 13, 2024)

Newsweek, She Stole Millions From Taxpayers to Buy Show Horses. Biden Set Her Free (December 13, 2024)

The Hill, Who are the people convicted in Capitol Riot Trump could pardon? (December 14, 2024)

Reason, Biden Issues More Pardons and Commutations Under Pressure From Criminal Justice Groups (December 12, 2024)

Newsweek, Could Joe Biden Pardon Everyone on Death Row? (December 10, 2024)

Guardian, US shuts down prisons amid scrutiny over sexual abuse and crisis of suicides (December 5, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Biden Commutes CARES Act Home Confinement Sentences – Update for December 12, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BIDEN COMMUTATION WAVE BEGINNING?

CARESEnd230131Early this morning, President Biden announced that he is granting clemency to nearly 1,500 Americans – the most ever in a single day – sent to home confinement under the CARES Act, people who the White House says “were placed on home confinement during the COVID-19 pandemic and who have successfully reintegrated into their families and communities.”

He is also pardoning 39 people convicted of non-violent crimes, whose names are not yet available. The White House said, “These actions represent the largest single-day grant of clemency in modern history.”

Biden said in a separate statement,

I am pardoning 39 people who have shown successful rehabilitation and have shown commitment to making their communities stronger and safer. I am also commuting the sentences of nearly 1,500 people who are serving long prison sentences – many of whom would receive lower sentences if charged under today’s laws, policies, and practices. These commutation recipients, who were placed on home confinement during the COVID pandemic, have successfully reintegrated into their families and communities and have shown that they deserve a second chance.

I will take more steps in the weeks ahead. My Administration will continue reviewing clemency petitions to advance equal justice under the law, promote public safety, support rehabilitation and reentry, and provide meaningful second chances.

Associated Press reported that the second largest single-day act of clemency was by Barack Obama, with 330, shortly before leaving office in 2017.

earlychristmas241212

Back in the final hours of the first Trump Administration, the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel issued an opinion that those persons serving sentences on CARES Act home confinement  would be required to return to secure custody once the national COVID emergency ended. The Justice Department subsequently withdrew that opinion, but with the election of President Trump, there has been substantial speculation – such as this, this and this –that the 2021 opinion could be once again adopted along with calls for Biden to preemptively block such a step with a blanket commutation.

Advocacy groups have been calling for a broad range of pardons, including for people on federal death row and with marijuana convictions. Biden has previously issued blanket pardons for those convicted of minor marijuana-related crimes, but those didn’t make any federal inmates eligible for release, because none of the recipients was in prison.

When Biden issued the blanket pardon in October 2022 for people convicted of marijuana possession on federal property, those benefitting were required to make individual applications to the Dept of Justice for the pardon specific to their cases. As of 6 a.m., details of what, if any, steps CARES Act recipients may have to take to obtain their personal commutations is not yet known.

White House, Release on CARES Act Clemency (December 12, 2024)

White House, Statement on CARES Act Clemency (December 12, 2024)

Associated Press, Biden commutes roughly 1,500 sentences and pardons 39 people in biggest single-day act of clemency (December 12, 2024)

Wall Street Journal, Biden to Commute Sentences of Around 1,500 People (December 12, 2024)

Dept. of Justice, Memorandum Opinion for the General Counsel of the Federal Bureau of Prisons (January 15, 2021)

Dept. of Justice, Discretion to Continue the Home-Confinement Placements of Federal Prisoners After the COVID-19 Emergency  (December 21, 2021)

Hurwitz, Hugh, Biden’s easy case for clemency: prisoners in home confinement (The Hill, November 26, 2024)

Pavlo, Walter, The Bureau of Prisons Under A Trump Administration (Forbes, November 7, 2024)

Ward, Myah, Clemency groups use Hunter pardon to pressure Biden (Politico, December 5, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Joe Biden Does a Father’s Duty… Now Who Might Be Next? – Update for December 2, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BIDEN PARDONS HUNTER… WHO MIGHT BE NEXT?

President Joe Biden pardoned his son, Hunter, last night, saving him prison time for gun possession offenses and tax crimes.

pardonme190123I will not listen to criticism for his action, regardless of the fact that the President recklessly claimed last summer he would never do such a thing. What father would not spare his son’s conviction and prison if it was in his power to do so? Even if Joe’s rationale – that no one is ever prosecuted for the 18 USC § 922(g)(3) and 18 USC § 922(a)(6) offenses that Hunter faced, and for his son to be indicted was raw political theater – is bullshit on stilts.

And it is. Somehow Joe omitted mention of Hunter’s tax convictions, those being of a nature and severity that are brought every day. As for the gun offenses, look at United States v. Daniels at Note 6, where a concurring judge chronicles other cases in that Circuit alone where (g)(3) offenses were brought against people who blew a little dope but were not intoxicated when they bought their guns.

Yes, Hunter’s gun offense was pretty pedestrian (but the (g)(3) conviction was probably unconstitutional, as Daniels explains). Still, if I were elected president (an event unlikely to happen), I would pardon any of my kids or siblings or parents or cousins in a heartbeat. It’s family.

In a statement released Sunday, Biden said, “I believe in the justice system, but as I have wrestled with this, I also believe raw politics has infected this process and it led to a miscarriage of justice.”

No reasonable person who looks at the facts of Hunter’s cases can reach any other conclusion than Hunter was singled out only because he is my son,” Biden said. “I hope Americans will understand why a father and a President would come to this decision.

On Twitter (now inexplicably called “X”) last night, New York University law professor and clemency expert Rachel Barkow said, “This pardon of Hunter Biden better be the first of a huge flurry of commutations. There are so many cases even more deserving than this one that the Pardon Attorney has recommended granting, and they’re just waiting for Biden’s signature.”

pardonturkey231121There were others just earlier last week. On Monday, Peaches and Blossom became the 7th and 8th turkeys to be pardoned by Joe Biden in his presidential career. Law professor and clemency expert Mark Osler has noted that presidents could apply lessons from the annual Thanksgiving week event to their clemency practices:

First, it occurs regularly. Turkeys are pardoned every year, not just in the waning days of an administration. Second, decisions are made by objective specialists with the current chairman of the National Turkey Federation… responsible for managing a thorough selection process… Third, there are defined criteria. The finalists are selected based on their willingness to be handled, their health and their natural good looks. Fourth, attention is paid to making sure they thrive after their grant of clemency. After the ceremony, they are sent to Virginia Tech’s “Gobbler’s Rest” exhibit, where they are well cared for… This contrasts sharply with the process of giving clemency to humans… [The] procedure through which clemency is granted is irregular, run largely by biased generalists, devoid of consistent, meaningful criteria, and it does little to ensure success of individuals after their release.

That does not lessen the optimism that in the next 49 days, Biden will hit a home run, pardoning or commuting sentences for everyone from Jack Smith and Merrick Garland to people on death row, CARES Act prisoners and those left behind by the First Step Act’s nonretroactivity.

Democrats and criminal justice reform advocates continue to pressure Biden to use his presidential authority to pardon those currently in federal prison fng from drugs to tax evasion—particularly those awaiting execution for more serious charges. Last week, 54 people who received clemency over the past five presidential administrations asked Biden to be “bold and compassionate during your remaining time in office and grant clemency to the deserving applicants referred to you by the Office of the Pardon Attorney.”

The clemency recipients wrote that they each had received long, unjust sentences before they finally regained their freedom.

death200330Prior to last Monday’s turkey pardoning, the group Prison Policy Initiative blasted Biden for reneging on his campaign promise to end the federal death penalty. “More turkeys have been pardoned from dinner plates in the US than people have been granted clemency from death row,” PPI said in an Instagram post. “Biden’s days left in office are limited, but it’s not too late for him to spare everyone from federal death row (and cement his legacy for the better).”

The Quaker organization Friends Committee on National Legislation said last week that “since 1973 there have been 200 exonerations from death row and over 1,600 people killed, with 50 executions at the federal level.” The group is not asking Biden to pardon all 40 people awaiting capital punishment but instead to commute their sentences to life in prison.

Writing in The Hill last week, former Bureau of Prisons Director Hugh Hurwitz urged Biden to commute the sentences of people currently on CARES Act home confinement. “Now that President-elect Donald Trump is returning to the White House,” Hurwitz wrote, “those remaining in home confinement are again concerned that his administration will reverse course and send them back to prison. Only this time, they have been quietly living at home and working in our communities for almost five years. This uncertainty is creating a lot of anxiety among these people and their families… We do not know what a new Trump administration will do, but there is no reason for us to wait and see. Until Jan 20, Biden has the unique power to grant clemency. This group of people has proven to be trustworthy and safe in our society. If ever there was a case for clemency, this is it.”

compassion160124Whether any of these pressure tactics will be enough to motivate Biden to move on clemency is not clear. But with less than two months left in his presidency, the only real strategy clemency advocates have is to stress how history will view him if he does nothing at all. And that will be effective only to the extent that he cares at all about that.

Associated Press, Biden pardons his son Hunter despite previous pledges not to (December 1, 2024)

United States v. Daniels, 77 F.4th 337 (5th Cir. 2023)

White House, Statement from President Joe Biden (December 1, 2024)

TwitterX, @RachelBarkow (December 1, 2024)

CNN, The process to pardon turkeys is more rational than the one used for humans (November 19, 2018)

Natl Criminal Justice Assn, Hunter Biden Defense Hints That President Should Pardon Him (November 30, 2024)

Tag24, Biden Urged to Take “Last Opportunity” for Positive Legacy in Letter from Over 50 Clemency Recipients (November 26, 2024)

Politico. Biden pardoned turkeys. Will he pardon more people? (November 26, 2024)

Prison Policy Initiative, More turkeys have been pardoned from dinner plates in the US than people have been granted clemency from death row (November 26, 2024)

The Hill, Biden’s easy case for clemency: prisoners in home confinement (November 26, 2024)

NCJA.Org, Death Penalty Opponents Seeking Commutations From Biden (November 26, 2024)

Friends Committee on National Legislation, Recommendations for Executive Action for the Remainder of President Biden’s Term (November 26, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Thanksgiving Week: A Heaping Serving of Yams – Update for Thanksgivng Day 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

YAMS

A true yam (as opposed to a sweet potato) is a monocot, a vigorous herbaceous, perennially growing vine related to lilies and grasses.

yams241128Speaking of “grass,” the marijuana kind, reports last week suggest that Biden’s promise to reclassify marijuana as a Schedule III drug – his latest promise to undo the war on drugs – might be in trouble .

Marijuana reform advocates last week asked an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) to remove the DEA from its own hearing. They argue the agency has improperly communicated with antimarijuana groups in a bid to torpedo the Biden administration’s proposal. The advocates contended that “prominent doctors, researchers and state regulation experts are not being allowed to testify in a hearing” that will enable the ALJ to recommend whether rescheduling is appropriate.

Last week, the Washington Post reported, ALJ “signaled he will side with the DEA, writing the advocates’ request “adds nothing” and “presents little more than an ad hominem distraction.”

Under the reclassification proposal, marijuana would not be legalized federally like alcohol or tobacco, but would move to Schedule III, a category including prescription drugs such as ketamine, anabolic steroids and testosterone. That could lead to a lessening of Guidelines sentencing ranges, but even if that happens, it won’t happen immediately.

The ALJ pushed back the hearing from December 2nd to some time in January or February because it was unclear whether the 25 witnesses submitted by the DEA favored or opposed reclassification, or even why they should be allowed to testify, according to the ruling.

fail200526Reason magazine last week chronicled Biden’s criminal justice failures: “His voluminous 2020 criminal justice platform (now scrubbed from his website) advocated eliminating mandatory minimum sentences, cash bail, and the federal death penalty.” Another article noted that besides the death penalty, Biden “promised to “eliminate mandatory minimums”; “end, once and for all, the federal crack and powder cocaine disparity”; “decriminalize the use of cannabis and automatically expunge all prior cannabis use convictions”; and “use the president’s clemency power to secure the release of individuals facing unduly long sentences for certain non-violent and drug crimes.”

So far, Joe’s 0 for 5, and number 6 – use of clemency – hangs in the balance, with 54 days left.

Washington Post, DEA faces legal challenge as uncertainty clouds plan to reclassify marijuana (November 19, 2024)

Reason, Biden Failed To Deescalate the Drug War (November 22, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Thanksgiving Week: Pardon Me If I Serve Up Turkey – Update for November 25, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

TURKEY TIME FOR JOE BIDEN

Today, Minnesota turkey farmer John Zimmerman and his son Grant visited the White House to see two of their prize turkeys, Peach and Blossom, receive presidential clemency, something that thousands of human federal prisoners would happily take the birds’ place in order to receive.

turkeypardonme241125President Joe Biden pardoned the 7th and 8th turkeys to receive clemency in his Administration. The spectacle is an annual Thanksgiving ritual that this year is being staged amid a clamor for Biden to issue a veritable feast of real pardons and commutations in the waning days of his Administration.

In the nearly four years he has been in office, Biden has granted 25 pardons and 132 commutations out of the thousands of applications filed. He has also pardoned two classes of people who were not incarcerated, people convicted of simple marijuana possession and members of the military who were court-martialed because of their sexual orientation.

Nearly all of the commutations have involved drug offenses. They number 38 more commutations than his predecessor, Donald Trump, granted in his first term, but fewer than one-tenth of the sentences Barack Obama commuted in his second term. About 8,002 petitions for clemency are pending (including for the two turkeys).

turkeyprison161114Last Wednesday, a gobbling flock of advocates, former prisoners, and families joined 67 congressional leaders in a joint letter urging President Biden to grant clemency to non-violent federal cannabis prisoners before his term ends.

Among federal prisoners, “90% of people are convicted of non-violent offenses. Now is the time to use your clemency authority to rectify unjust and unnecessary criminal laws passed by Congress and draconian sentences given by judges,” the letter says. “We urge you to use your executive clemency power to reunite families, address longstanding injustices in our legal system, and set our nation on the path toward ending mass incarceration.”

Reps Ayanna Pressley (D-MA), James Clyburn (D-SC), and Mary Gay Scanlon (D-PA) were lead signers of the letter.

pardonturkey231121Also, in a briefing last week, Prison Policy Initiative stated, “Although he’s extended pardons and commutations during his term, President Joe Biden has yet to use his clemency powers for a person facing the federal death penalty, despite openly opposing capital punishment at one time. Biden can still heed increasing calls from advocates to improve his minimal clemency record and clear federal death row of all 40 current death sentences… Given that president-elect Donald Trump enthusiastically supports the death penalty — and has historically abused the pardon power — President Biden could spare 40 lives immediately and reclaim the true function of clemency by commuting all federal death sentences.”

Not that President-elect Trump is anti-pardon. He loves them… for the right people.

Last week, a Trump-appointed federal judge said it would be “beyond frustrating and disappointing” if Trump grants sweeping clemency to most of the defendants charged in the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol. Federal Judge Carl Nichols (District of Columbia) blasted the prospect of “blanket pardons” or “anything close” during the sentencing of a defendant facing eight assault charges.

Politico said, “Nichols’ comments were a surprise from the typically restrained judge and came at the end of a hearing in which he and federal prosecutors grappled at length with the potential impact of Donald Trump’s election on ongoing Jan 6 cases. He added that “anything close to blanket clemency would be similarly frustrating.”

This American Life: America’s Next Top Gobble (November 15, 2024)

Guardian, Biden must Trump-proof US democracy, activists say: ‘There is a sense of urgency’ (November 24, 2024)

Letter to President Biden (November 20, 2024)

The Appeal, U.S. Reps Urge Biden to Use Clemency to Correct “Extreme Use of Incarceration” (November 20, 2024)

Prison Policy Initiative, Talking turkey about the death penalty: outgoing governors and the president must use their clemency power now (November 18, 2024)

Politico, Trump-appointed judge opposes ‘blanket pardons’ for Jan. 6 defendants (November 19, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root

Matt Gaetz: Mere Anarchy at the Dept of Justice – Update for November 19, 2024

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

THINGS FALL APART

thingsfall241119I tuned out the poetry we studied in high school English, which makes me wonder why President-elect Donald Trump’s announcement last week that Matt Gaetz would be his Attorney General made me recall W.B. Yeats’ work, The Second Coming:

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;

Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world;

The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere

The ceremony of innocence is drowned…

Trump has vowed to execute every prisoner on federal death row, to expand the federal death penalty to include drug traffickers and migrants who kill U.S. citizens, to use the military to round up and run out immigrants, and to grant all law enforcement officers immunity from criminal prosecution.

Writing in The Watch last week, Radley Balko observed that Trump “of course promised to weaponize federal law enforcement to settle grudges, exact retribution, and protect his interests.”

Congressman Matt Gaetz (R-FL) is slated to serve as Attorney General. Gaetz, whose legal career spans about three years as a junior associate in a small Florida law firm, has never tried a case nor managed an enterprise, but he’s intended to run the Dept of Justice, of which the Bureau of Prisons is a part.

pervert160728In 2020, Gaetz was accused of child sex trafficking and statutory rape over claims that he paid a 17-year-old high school student for sex. Following an investigation, DOJ decided not to seek charges, concerned that it might not be able to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. Gaetz resigned from the House last week just before the House Ethics Committee was to release a report on the sex charges, alleged drug use and other misconduct.

One DOJ official said of the nomination, “What the f— is happening?!” Another said that Gaetz is the “least qualified person ever nominated for a position in the Department of Justice.”

MSNBC admitted that “in a sense, everybody is unqualified” to serve as Attorney General, because DOJ “is so deep, broad and complex that no one can come in truly prepared for all of it. Nobody comes in knowing everything about tax or antitrust or civil rights or criminal or civil or environmental work. They do not know the intricacies of the work of its many divisions, from the Federal Bureau of Prisons to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.” But, MSNBC argued, AGs need “three qualities: integrity, judgment and independence. With those qualities, you can handle the job… [W]ith Gaetz, you might end up with somebody who is wholly unqualified for the job coupled with somebody who lacks integrity, judgment and independence.”

But why should federal prisoners care? It might be beneficial to have a man who had once been a DOJ target running things.

dungeon180627Don’t count on it. As a state legislator, Gaetz sponsored a bill requiring the Florida governor to sign death warrants for prisoners on death row as soon as their appeals were exhausted. Last July, Gaetz toured El Salvador’s notorious Terrorism Confinement Center where, CNN reported, “convicts and pretrial detainees “spend 23½ hours a day in bleak group cells, eat a bland meatless diet and have just 30 minutes a day for exercise or Bible class.”

“There’s a lot more discipline in this prison than we see in a lot of the prisons in the United States,” Gaetz said at the time. “We think the good ideas in El Salvador actually have legs and can go to other places and help other people be safe and secure and hopeful and prosperous.”

In other transition news, Sen. John Thune (R-SD) will serve as Majority Leader—the person who will control which bills are voted on—in the new Senate, which convenes on Jan 3, 2025. Thune has consistently opposed even modest marijuana reform proposals, once calling legalization a “dangerous path.”

In 2021, Thune acknowledged that marijuana is an “area that’s still evolving, and our country’s views on it are evolving,” adding that “how we deal with it nationally, is still an open question.”

President Biden promised in 2022 that rescheduling marijuana from Schedule I to Schedule III – which could lead to the easing of criminal penalties – would be done by the end of 2024. A DEA hearing on the matter is set for December 4. It’s not clear that final rules can be rolled out before a new and possibly hostile Congress is seated.

Radley Balko – Substack, The “broligarch” threat to criminal justice reform (November 13, 2024)

NBC, Justice Dept. employees stunned at Trump’s ‘insane,’ ‘unbelievable’ choice of Matt Gaetz for attorney general (November 10, 2024)

MSNBC, An attorney general needs 3 qualities to be successful. Matt Gaetz doesn’t even have one. (November 14, 2024)

CNN, Matt Gaetz would oversee US prisons as AG. He thinks El Salvador’s hardline lockups are a model (November 14, 2024)

Marijuana Moment, Every GOP Senate Majority Leader Candidate Opposes Marijuana Legalization (November 12, 2024)

– Thomas L. Root