Tag Archives: BOP

A Couple of Odds and Ends – Update for July 2, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

shorts210702WE’VE GOT THE SHORTS

COVID Numbers: The BOP reported 31 inmates and 137 staff sick with COVID as of yesterday. The virus was still in 64 institutions. As of last FridaY, the agency said 51.9% of its staff and 53.1% of inmates have been vaccinated.

As I have previously reported, no one trusts the BOP numbers.

BOP, COVID-19 Coronavirus

Judge Goes After Marshals: US District Judge Charles Kornmann (DSD) levied criminal contempt charges against three senior US Marshal officials last week arising from his demand to know whether Marshals in his courtroom have been vaccinated against COVID-19.

angryjudge190822The charges stemmed from an incident last month in which the Judge asked a deputy marshal whether she had been vaccinated. When she refused to answer, Kornmann ordered her out of his courtroom. The Marshals responded by removing three defendants awaiting a hearing from the courthouse, in what Judge Kornmann described as a “kidnapping” that disrupted the court’s work.

The US Attorney for South Dakota has refused to prosecute the criminal contempt citations. As of Wednesday, Judge Kornmann had appointed a Rapid City, South Dakota, private attorney to try the case, and the Judge had recused himself. The Judge described the contretemps as follows:

The Department of Justice, acting through the Marshal Service, has apparently adopted a public policy to the effect that DOJ policies may trump lawful federal court orders. This cannot be permitted. Despite some public confusion, this case has nothing to do with requiring anyone to be fully vaccinated.

Josh Blackman, a constitutional law professor at the South Texas College of Law Houston, wrote in the Volokh Conspiracy blog that

recusal seems like an obvious move. This judge has clearly made up his mind. The case is so personal. There is no pretense of objectivity at this point. The case is styled United States of America v. John Kilhallon, et al. But the Plaintiff is not the United States. It is a single judge who abused his discretion. Judge Kornmann makes Judge Emmet Sullivan seem reasonable by comparison.

As for me, I really don’t know who to cheer against in this one. But I am pretty sure I can identify the losers: those federal pretrial defendants sitting in local jails waiting for hearings that will be delayed by this kerfuffle.

Washington Post, Federal judge accuses three senior law enforcement officials of criminal obstruction (June 14, 2021)

Jamestown Sun, South Dakota’s acting US Attorney won’t participate in contempt of court case against US marshals (June 25, 2021)

The Volokh Conspiracy, Update from South Dakota: Judge Kornmann Appoints Special Prosecutor To Try U.S. Marshals For Contempt (June 30, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

Will BOP Director Carvajal Be The Next One to Be Sent Home? – Update for June 29, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

SOME BOP HONCHOS GET EARLY RELEASE, AND CARVAJAL MAY BE NEXT

hitroad210629The Associated Press reported last Wednesday that two Federal Bureau of Prisons Regional Directors have been relieved of their posts. Senior Biden administration officials are also considering replacing Director Michael Carvajal, whom the AP describes as being “at the center” of the “beleaguered agency’s myriad crises.”

The discussions about whether to fire Carvajal are in the preliminary stages and a final decision hasn’t yet been made, AP said it had been told by two people familiar with the matter. They were not authorized to publicly discuss the internal talks and spoke on condition of anonymity.

However, AP reported, “there’s an indication that the bureau is shaking up its senior ranks following growing criticism of chronic mismanagement, blistering reports from the Justice Department’s inspector general, and a bleak financial outlook.”

shocked191024Mismanagement at the BOP? I’m shocked.

“Since the death of Jeffrey Epstein at a federal lockup in New York in August 2019,” the AP claimed, “Associated Press has exposed one crisis after another, including rampant spread of coronavirus inside prisons and a failed response to the pandemic, escapes, deaths and critically low staffing levels that have hampered responses to emergencies.”

At least two regional directors, officials in charge of institutions in the South Central and the Southeast regions are also being replaced. BOP said the two regional directors — Juan Baltazar, Jr. and J.A. Keller — are retiring and had been planning to do so. But the sudden removal apparently was not the testimonial dinner and gold watch the two had anticipated: other people familiar with the matter said that neither had planned to leave for months and were told other officials were being appointed to their jobs.

On Wednesday, AP said, the BOP announced it was appointing wardens William Lothrop and Heriberto Tellez to the regional posts. Tellez, one of the “morons” recently referred to by Senior US District Judge Colleen McMahon, is currently in charge of MDC Brooklyn, the high-rise dungeon where a 34-year-old inmate was found dead in his cell as recently as a week ago.

Carvajal took over as director in February 2020, a month before COVID-19 began galloping through all 122 of the BOP’s facilities, infecting over 48,000 inmates and killing 255.

reel210629To be sure, the Director does not have a lot of highlights on his reel.  Nearly a third of BOP correctional officer jobs are vacant, forcing the BOP to continue to use augmentation, pressing medical, educational, office, and other staff into temporary CO duty.

Some question whether the staffing shortage will prevent the agency from maintaining security and at the same time carrying out its First Step Act programming duties. Over the past 18 months, 30 prisoners have escaped from federal lockups across the U.S. — and nearly half still have not been caught. The AP said prisoners have broken out at lockups in nearly every region of the country.

The Bureau has said it expects to bring on 1,800 new employees, and that its recent hiring initiative has been “a huge success.” But the AP reports the BOP has been slow-walking its hiring process, pausing most new hires until at least October. Officers at several facilities have held protests calling for Carvajal to be fired.

Late last week, Shane Fausey, national president of the Council of Prison Locals, AFL-CIO (representing 30,000 BOP employees) told Politico, “A clear and dangerous staffing crisis in the Bureau of Prisons, as explicitly outlined in a number of OIG reports and a recent scathing report by the GAO, has pushed this agency beyond its limits. Our employees and officers continue to endure unrelenting overtime and reassignments as the budgetary shortfall is preventing the hiring of much needed Correctional Officers.”

Meanwhile, President Biden’s detailed 2022 BOP budget request does not throw the BOP a life preserver. It includes a reduction of $267 million to reflect decreases in the BOP’s inmate population — a decrease that is a result, in part, of the CARES Act and increased use of the Elderly Offenders Home Detention program.

Jail151220But it’s not just the staff shortage and cash crunch. The BOP continues to be plagued by embarrassing allegations of misconduct. Although this predates Carvajal’s administration, a loaded gun was found smuggled into MCC New York not long after Epstein committed suicide. In the last month, the DOJ Inspector General issued a report about security lapses at BOP minimum-security facilities. Last week, the family of Jamel Floyd – who died a year ago at MDC Brooklyn after being pepper-sprayed by guards (only a few months before scheduled release after 15 years) – sued the BOP.

The Floyd suit came only a few days after a suit filed in Denver by BOP employees alleged that USP Florence special operations (SORT) team members fired pepper spray, plastic bullets, and pepper balls at their unarmed, administrative colleagues during a training exercise, in “inappropriate and dangerous” training episodes. Those failings prompted the DOJ Inspector General to recommend that some of its special operations training be suspended until better safeguards could be put in place.

“We believe that staff members at the Bureau of Prisons abused their coworkers in a way that undermines, or should undermine, the faith of the public in the ability to do their jobs,” said attorney Ed Aro, who is representing four current and former Bureau of Prison employees who say they were injured and traumatized by the training.

Last week, Vanity Fair published a long piece chronicling pretrial detainee Ghislaine Maxwell’s complaints about inhumane treatment at MCC New York.

And we end with an Eastern District of Virginia federal judge last week angrily and publicly blaming the BOP for the suicide death of a presentence defendant.

angryjudge190822The man had been sent to FMC Butner – a BOP medical and psychiatric center – for a mental evaluation. He was declared competent to enter a plea and returned to a local jail. After the man pled guilty but before sentencing, Judge T.S. Ellis III again became concerned about the man’s mental health and ordered him back to FMC Butner for further care.  BOP officials refused him unless the defendant was deemed incompetent again or required a new psychiatric evaluation. So the defendant went to a local jail where he took his own life on May 18.

At a hearing on June 24, the judge excoriated the BOP for refusing to take the man and failing to provide his medical records to the local jail. “If I issue an order, you must obey it,” he told prison officials who participated in the hearing. “Nobody in the Bureau of Prisons should ever decide they don’t want to obey my order because they think it violates the law. I trump their view of the law.”

Welcome to the culture of the BOP, Your Honor.

Associated Press, AP sources: Officials mulling ousting US prisons director (June 23, 2021)

Newsweek, Trump-Appointed Bureau of Prisons Director Michael Carvajal Could Be Replaced Amid Crises (June 23, 2021)

Midnight Report, Federal Bureau of Prisons Oust Regional Directors in South Central and Southeast Regions (June 23, 2021)

Time, After His 2020 Death in a New York Jail Cell, Jamel Floyd’s Family File Lawsuit Against Bureau of Prisons (June 24, 2021)

Denver Post, Supermax special ops team used pepper spray, plastic bullets on unarmed colleagues during training exercise, lawsuit alleges (June 23, 2021)

Politico, Union boss: Bureau of Prisons faces dangerous cash crunch (June 25, 2021)

Vanity Fair, Inside Ghislaine Maxwell’s Battle With the Bureau of Prisons (June 24, 2021)

Washington Post, Judge faults federal prison system after suicide of Great Falls man (June 25, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

The Clock Chimes 13 Times for BOP COVID Response – Update for June 25, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

REMEMBER COVID? IT’S STILL AROUND IN THE BOP… AND PEOPLE ARE STILL DYING

The Bureau of Prisons reported 61 sick inmates and 136 sick staff in 65 facilities as of last night.

COVIDdeath201001

What is curious is that the BOP reported two more inmate COVID deaths last week.

One was from last December. With its usual opacity, the BOP reported last week that on “Friday, December 4, 2020, inmate Carlous Lindell Daily tested positive for COVID-19 at the United States Penitentiary (USP) Victorville in Victorville, California, and was immediately placed in medical isolation. On Wednesday, December 23, 2020, in accordance with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidelines, Mr. Daily was considered recovered after completing isolation and presenting with no symptoms.”

[Editorial note here: The BOP always trots out the justification in notices like these that ‘we only said he was recovered because the CDC guidelines said he was recovered’. I have heard from too many inmates that ‘recovery’ consists of taking a temperature. The inmates are listed as presenting no symptoms because staff is careful not to ask the inmates about any symptoms].

To be sure, poor Mr. Daily must have been experiencing some continuing symptoms that the crack BOP medical professionals overlooked. Only five days after he was declared fit as a fiddle, “[o]n Monday, December 28, 2020, Mr. Daily experienced vomiting and an altered mental status, and while being treated, became unresponsive. Responding staff immediately initiated life-saving measures. Staff requested emergency medical services (EMS) and life-saving efforts continued. Mr. Daily was subsequently pronounced deceased by EMS personnel.”

Apparently, the Health Services staff was so crushed by losing their ‘recovered’ patient that no one got around to reporting his death for over five months.

clock210625I remember from years ago a judge patiently explaining to a greenhorn lawyer (me) about the 13th chime. The ’13th chime’ comes from the mythical case of Rex v. Haddock, recounted in book Uncommon Law by A.P. Herbert.  Some have attributed it to an earlier utterance by Mark Twain. Regardless of its origin, the ’13th Chime” doctrine holds that when a clock strikes 13 times, not only is the 13th strike itself discredited, but the very fact that there was a 13th chime raises doubts about the accuracy of the preceding 12. Twain allegedly said: “The thirteenth stroke of the clock is not only false of itself, but casts grave doubt on the credibility of the preceding twelve”.

The point is this: I have heard for months from inmate correspondents that people were dying at FCI XYZ of COVID, but FCI XYZ’s reported deaths never seemed to reflect inmate folklore. Mr. Daily’s demise is the second time in three weeks that the BOP issued a way-after-the-fact admission about a death that went unreported during the height of the epidemic. How many more of these unreported deaths – which, had they been reported in a timely manner, would have made BOP conditions during the pandemic look even direr – are lurking out there? What’s more, the under-reporting is consistent with the BOP practice many prisoners have reported of medical staff doing the ostrich thing, not inquiring about symptoms other than to take a temperature?

ostrich170228Certainly, under-reporting would not surprise The Marshall Project, which has been criticizing  BOP sleight-of-hand on case numbers for months:

The Federal Bureau of Prisons also had a policy of removing cases and deaths from its reports. As a result, by the spring of 2021, we could no longer accurately determine new cases in federal prisons, which had more people infected than any other system.

Now for the other death last week, Sherri Hillman, a pretrial detainee who died at the abattoir known as FMC Carswell, the BOP’s only women’s medical center at Fort Worth.

die210625The circumstances around the Carswell death were painfully similar to the April death of Martha Evanoff at that facility. According to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Sherri had been sent to Carswell while awaiting sentencing in Kentucky, after being hospitalized with COVID since January. “She was transferred to (Carswell) in Fort Worth because most people thought she would be getting better care there than in Kentucky,” her attorney told the newspaper.

Her mother said, however, “from what she was telling me, I just don’t think she was treated right.” Two other Carswell inmates told the paper said they heard Sherri crying out for help for several days from her cell on the medical floor. One woman, who is also staying on the medical floor, said she heard the shouting.

“Everyone on the floor heard her screaming for help for several days,” a witness, who did not want her name to be used out of fear of retaliation, told the Star-Telegram, “For days, they said she’s faking it and there’s nothing wrong with her, and they ignored her cries for help. She would say, ‘Please, somebody help me.’”

Another inmate reported to me, “The poor woman begged for 4-5 days for help and was told to ‘shut up’.”

Sherri died alone in her cell on June 14.

BOP, Inmate Death at Victorville (June 17, 2021)

BOP, Inmate Death at FMC Carswell (June 17, 2021)

Fort Worth TX Star-Telegram, Woman told mother, ‘I can’t do this anymore,’ before death at prison in Fort Worth (June 17, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

“Did We Nail That Pandemic, Or What?” – Update for May 6, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

TELL US HOW WE’RE DOING

howwedoing210506The Dept of Justice Office of Inspector General announced last week that it would be conducting a second survey of BOP staff and a first survey of inmates to determine how well the BOP performed during the pandemic.

The results of the surveys should be illuminating.

And how are things now? As of last Friday, the BOP said it has given two doses of vaccine to about 35% of all inmates, and about 49% of staff. About 126 inmates are sick with COVID-19, and 164staff, with COVID still present in 67% of facilities, if BOP numbers can be believed.

numbers180327But can the numbers be believed? The Marshall Project and Associated Press, which jointly have been tracking how many people are being sickened and killed by COVID-19 in prisons across the country and within each state since March 2020, have given up on BOP numbers, warning that “our understanding of the full toll of the pandemic on incarcerated people is limited by the Federal Bureau of Prisons’ policy of removing cases and deaths from its reports in recent months. As a result, we cannot accurately determine new cases or deaths in federal prisons, which have had more people infected than any other system.”

Another federal inmate died of COVID last week, this one at FMC Devens. Paul Archambault contracted COVID-19 at the end of December but was declared “recovered” ten days later. The “recovery” label appears to have benefited record-keeping more than Mr. Archambault. Like a number of others before him, he died of the COVID-19 from which he had recovered.

rehabB160812In New York last week, U.S. District Judge Katherine Polk Failla granted compassionate release to an inmate at MCC Manhattan, ruling that a key part of her sentence was addiction treatment and care for other ailments. The judge said the BOP hasn’t provided it to the inmate, who was serving a sentence for a cocaine conspiracy.

“Due to the extreme lockdown conditions at the [Metropolitan Correctional Center] and [Metropolitan Detention Center], the inmate has been unable to receive mental health care, drug abuse treatment, and other important services that the Court envisioned her receiving while incarcerated,” the judge wrote. “The Court believes these services to be critical to her physical and mental health, and to her ability to reenter society as a productive and law-abiding citizen.”

DOJ Inspector General, Surveys of BOP Federal Prison Staff and Inmates (April 28, 2021)

The Marshall Project, A State-by-State Look at Coronavirus in Prisons (April 30, 2021)

BOP, Inmate Death at FMC Devens (April 29, 2021)

New York Daily News, Judge, inmate slam conditions at NYC federal jails in pandemic’s 13th month (April 26, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

BOP’s Secret Home Confinement Memo Sows Confusion – Update for April 26, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

DUELING HOME CONFINEMENT MEMOS DRAW CRITICISM

A week ago, I wrote about a new Bureau of Prisons memo (which some said was really a Dept of Justice memo) expanding eligibility for CARES Act home confinement. I admitted that despite my efforts, I could not obtain a copy of it.

secret210426I’m not alone. FAMM was scrambling, inmates were scrambling, and even Ohio State University law professor Doug Berman, the dean of federal sentencing law if there ever was one, complained in his Sentencing Law and Policy blog last Tuesday that the memo has still not been released. That same day, Keri Blakinger of The Marshall Project released what purported to be the text of the memo, a well-meant but ultimately unhelpful post.

Meanwhile, my email was smoking. Inmates heard that the BOP had been told to send minimum-security inmates home even if they had not served half of their sentence, the standard that people with prior offenses of violence were excluded had been dropped… the institutions were rife with rumors. People complained that their case managers were stubbornly ignoring the new standards, that wardens were releasing internal memos that underpromised.

You remember the game “post office.” The message was whispered around the circle of kids until it returned to the source mangled beyond recognition. That’s what we had. And the blame can be laid at the bureaucratic feet of the Bureau of Prisons, which would classify road signs as “sensitive” and “FOIA exempt” if the agency could get away with it.

Thankfully, Washington, D.C., leaks like a screen door on a submarine. By Then, on Thursday, both FAMM and the Defenders Services Office of the Administrative Office of U.S. Court (the support agency for Federal Public Defenders nationwide) had obtained bootlegged copies of the memo – an April 13 release from Andre Mateviousian, Assistant Director of the Correctional Services Division, BOP – and posted them on the Internet. These posts, which are identical, appear to be the real deal.

So what changed? A couple of things. First, inmates with -300 and -400 series disciplinary reports shots in the last 12 months are not automatically disqualified. Second, inmates with “low” PATTERN scores are now eligible for CARES Act home confinement.

violence151213What didn’t change? At least a couple of things. First, if you have a prior conviction for a crime of violence (let’s say a bar fight back in 1985, when you were 21 years old and possessed a testosterone-addled brain), you are still disqualified from CARES Act home confinement (no matter that you’re doing 24 months for tearing the label off your mattress). Second, the BOP is adhering to its self-imposed standard that you have to have completed 50% of your sentence (or 25% of your sentence with less than 18 months to go).

So the Marshall Project text was wrong: prior violence still counts. The versions of the memo posted by FAMM and fd.org continue to say that “the inmate’s current or a prior offense” cannot be “violent, a sex offense, or terrorism-related.”

At the end of last week. FAMM President Kevin Ring wrote to the BOP complaining about its failure to officially release the memo. “I am writing to ask that you publish on the Bureau of Prisons’ (BOP) website any and all memos sent to wardens about the eligibility criteria for CARES Act home confinement,” Ring wrote. “The BOP’s failure to do so has created unnecessary confusion and frustration for incarcerated people and their families…”

There is not a bureaucratic reason on God’s green earth why the BOP could not have released the memorandum on April 13, 2021. Instead, the agency’s obsession with secrecy (or at least playing its cards close to the vest) generated a week’s worth of heat without light. In fact, if the memo had not been leaked to outside organizations, inmates would still be in a tizzy and families still confused.

winnie210426While I am on a rant, I should note the moment in BOP Director Michael Carvajal’s testimony two weeks ago before the Senate Judiciary Committee that made me shout “liar!” at my computer screen. That in turn caused my faithful and efficient office dog Winnie to cower under a table until I calmed down.

As I note, the new memorandum retains the 50%-of-sentence requirement. This is a standard that Attorney General William Barr never imposed. Instead, as you may remember, it was the BOP’s own fiat, added in the agency’s all-too-typical ham-handed way (with inmates who were literally walking out the door to return home being called back because of the new requirement).

When I heard Carvajal assure the Senators that all the BOP had done was to apply the AG’s home confinement criteria, I was disgusted at his prevarication and furious that the Senators were so ill-prepared by their staffs that no one called Carvajal out on the fib.

In Forbes last week, Walter Pavlo noted it as well. He too observed that the time-served requirement was not dictated by the Attorney General, but rather was

based on an internal BOP memorandum that stated it was screening inmates based on whether they had served 25% of their sentence with less than 18 months remaining or have served more than 50% of their sentence. The directive had little logic behind it because COVID-19 did not discriminate between those who had been in prison years or those who had just arrived. The result of the memorandum was devastating, leading to deaths and infections at everyone of the BOP facilities nationwide.

liar151213Testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee two weeks ago, BOP Director Michael Carvajal said that “…any inmate that is eligible under the criteria presented to me by the Attorney General is on home confinement as we speak.” Pavlo called that misleading, noting that “what Carvajal failed to add were details of the internal memos that mandated that priority for a person’s transfer to home confinement be measured against the amount of time they had served…”

Carvajal’s statement was false then, and it is false now.

Sentencing Law and Policy, Why is DOJ apparently keeping hidden a new memo expanding the criteria for home confinement? (April 20, 2021)

The Marshall Project, Document Cloud, Home Confinement Memo (April 20, 2021)

FAMM, BOP Home Confinement Memorandum of April 13, 2021 (posted April 21, 2021)

Federal Public Defender, BOP Home Confinement Memorandum of April 13, 2021 (posted April 21, 2021)

Sentencing Law and Policy, FAMM urges federal BOP to publish memos with home confinement criteria (April 23, 2021)

Forbes, Bureau of Prisons Director Testimony To Senate Judiciary Leaves Unanswered Questions (April 20, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

The Week in COVID – Update for April 22, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

COVID BY THE (DIMINISHING) NUMBERS

The number of BOP staff with COVID fell dramatically last week from 1,254 to 252, but the spike now sweeping the country showed up among BOP prisoners, with the numbers increasing from 208 a week ago Monday to 408 two days ago,  only to drop back to 336 as of today. The BOP says that COVID is still present in 82 facilities, but that is down from 115 a week before.

COVIDvaccine201221BOP Director Michael Carvajal told the Senate Judiciary Committee that all BOP staff had been offered the vaccine, and 51% had taken it. He said 66% of inmates offered the vaccine had taken it. The BOP reported 40,808 inmates have been vaccinated as of last Friday (26.8%), up from 23.04% a week ago, The number suggests that the vaccine has been offered to about 61,800 inmates so far. Carvajal said all inmates would be offered the vaccine by the end of May.

The “pause” in administering the Johnson & Johnson vaccine last week because of two reports of a rare blood disorder is expected to be lifted in the next few days. While Dr. Anthony Fauci has said that the pause should be viewed as a “testimony to how seriously we take safety,” some experts are worried that the pause could lead to increased vaccine hesitancy, particularly in vulnerable populations that might be less likely to trust medical institutions in the first place, such as prisons.

“Vaccine confidence tends to be lower amongst people who have been disenfranchised,” Dr. Wafaa El-Sadr, a Columbia University professor of epidemiology and medicine told ABC News. “Among incarcerated people, that hesitancy may be tied to a historical legacy of doctors experimenting on people in prison.”

fearofvaccination210422At last week’s BOP oversight hearing, Judiciary Committee members expressed concern about the low vaccine acceptance rate among BOP staff. Sen Amy Klobuchar (D-Minnesota) noted that “95% of Mayo clinic doctors have been vaccinated because they don’t want to give it to their patients.” She wondered why BOP staffers were not similarly motivated to protect inmates by getting vaccinated.

ABC News, Prisons postpone vaccinations with Johnson & Johnson shots paused (April 16, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

Odd Couple Beat Up on Prison Head – Update for April 20, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction  matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

SENATORS UNHAPPY OVER FIRST STEP IMPLEMENTATIONS

oddcouple210219Last Thursday’s Senate Judiciary Committee Oversight hearing opened with Committee chair Richard Durbin (D-Illinois) and Ranking Member Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) both blasting the BOP not just for its failures in placing inmates in home confinement, but for the PATTERN recidivism tool – which Durbin called “deeply flawed” – and for what they see as BOP slow-walking implementation of First Step Act programming.

Durbin complained that PATTERN contained “stunning racial disparity in inmate classification, and that the BOP’s proposed rule for awarding earned time credit – which requires 240 actual hours of programs for one month’s credit – “severely limits the ability to earn these credits, and that undermines participation.”

“Our prison system at the federal level is failing,” Durbin said in his opening remarks, “failing to fulfill its fundamental purpose, the rehabilitation of incarcerated individuals.”

Grassley said he was “disheartened with the lackluster implementation of the First Step Act. “The DOJ and Bureau of Prisons are implementing the First Step Act as if they want it to fail. I hope this is not true but actions speak louder than words.”

BOP Director Michael Carvajal said that COVID had hampered full rollout of the programming inmates could complete for earned credits that reduced their sentences, but Grassley responded, “I don’t think that national eFSAsabotage210420mergency can be used as a scapegoat… It seems like the Justice Department and the Bureau of Prisons have failed in this effort… Even if it isn’t so, at some point it becomes a perception, and perceptions become a reality.”

Carvajal told the Committee that about 50% of the 125,000 inmates reviewed were eligible to take programming for earned time credits. He told the Committee that last year, “even through COVID, we had over 25,000 inmates complete a program for time credit.”

This was a surprising admission, in my view. In litigation, the BOP has argued that its obligation to implement the evidence-based reduction programs and award Earned Time credits will not take effect until January 2022. That position – already rejected by several courts – seems to be undercut by Carvajal’s statement to lawmakers that 25,000 inmates got some ETC credit during 2020.

Senate Judiciary Committee, Oversight of the Bureau of Prisons (April 15, 2021)

Goodman v. Ortiz, Case No 20-7582, 2020 US Dist LEXIS 153874 (DNJ Aug 25, 2020)

– Thomas L. Root

Judiciary Committee Exercised Over Home Confinees Returning to Prison – Update for April 16, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

LOBBYING EFFORT ON CARES ACT HOME CONFINEMENT MAY BE BEARING FRUIT

FAMM started to turn up the heat last week on an effort to get President Joe Biden and Attorney General Merrick Garland to rescind the January 15 memo from DOJ’s Office of Legal Counsel that would lead to the return of people now on home confinement under CARES Act placement to federal prison when the pandemic ends.

The memo was a prime topic yesterday when Bureau of Prisons Director Michael Carvajal testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Judging from the questions coming from both Republicans and Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee (with the exception of the execrable Sen. Tom Cotton [R-Klingon Empire] and Sen. Josh Hawley [R-Mongol Horde]), the FAMM campaign is bearing fruit.

hawley2100416

The OLC memo, issued in the final days of the Trump administration, would force the BOP to send several thousand people currently on home confinement. Carvajal said it would probably affect somewhere around 2,500 people now on home confinement with a year or more to go on their sentences. A few more than 300 have lengthy sentences left. Of the group, he said 21 have been returned to BOP custody, but only two of those were because of new criminal conduct.

The memo is incorrect as a matter of law and would impose devastating human costs, as well as a negative impact on public safety. Sen. Richard Durbin (D-Illinois), chair of the Committee, said yesterday he was writing to Garland to urge him to reconsider his predecessor’s opinion.

FAMM and 28 other advocacy groups sent a letter to Biden and Garland on April 1st. FAMM has launched the “Keep Them Home” campaign, and is both collecting signatures on a petition and calling on people to call Garland’s office in order to get the Administration to rescind the memo.

home190109FAMM president Kevin Ring told The Appeal that those who were released did not expect to have to return to prison. “These folks came home and were told, ‘You’re not going to have to come back,’” Ring said. “They reunited with their families. Some of them have kids who they said, ‘I’m home.’ They said, ‘Do you have to go back, Dad?’ ‘No.’ So this changes everything.”

Earlier, the BOP declined to answer reporters’ questions about the memo, but Joe Rojas, Southeast Regional Vice President of the union representing BOP employees, said sending everyone back to prison would be logistically impossible. “We have no staff,” he told The Sentinel, “We are already in chaos as it is.”

But yesterday, Carvajal said that the BOP has ample space to absorb the home confinees if they were to return. Nevertheless, he expressed no opinion on whether they should come back. The Director noted that the issue is not immediate, because the pandemic emergency has been extended by the President.

home210218My take on Carvajal’s position (for what it’s worth) is that his bias leans toward leaving people who have complied with their home confinement terms at home. He said repeatedly that the BOP’s mission was to successfully return people to the committee, and as long as home confinees are successful at home, there was nothing wrong with leaving them there.

However, Carvajal said that the BOP’s primary interest was to follow the law, and he urged lawmakers to amend the home confinement statute to make clear what should be done.

The Appeal, Unless The Biden Administration Acts, Thousands Could Go Back To Federal Prison (April 5, 2021)

FAMM Petition

KSU The Sentinel, Inmates under house arrest in the event of a pandemic could return to prisons in the United States (April 11, 2021)

Senate Judiciary Committee, Oversight Hearing on Bureau of Prisons (April 15, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root

Thursday is Hamburger Day – Update for April 12, 2021

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BOP DIRECTOR TO BE GRILLED ABOUT COVID, FIRST STEP

hamburger160826Almost every inmate in the Bureau of Prisons system looks forward to Wednesdays, when the nationwide lunch menu serves sandwiches that pass for hamburgers, with a side of fries. But this week, BOP Director Michael Carvajal’s hamburger day may come one day later.

Carvajal will testify this Thursday before the full Senate Judiciary Committee in the first comprehensive BOP oversight hearing since 2019. Politico said last week that principal issues will include how BOP has handled the coronavirus pandemic and how it has implemented the First Step Act. “On both counts,” Politico reported, “the Bureau has drawn bipartisan criticism.”

A BOP statement last week said Director Carvajal “is looking forward to the opportunity to provide the Senate Judiciary Committee with information at the upcoming Oversight of the Federal Bureau of Prisons hearing on the morning of April 15, 2021.” Yeah, I have no doubt of that… like a dental patient eagerly anticipates a root canal without Novocain.

oddcouple210219At the hearing, Carvajal will face Sen. Richard Durbin (D-Illinois) — now the committee chair — former chairman Charles Grassley (R-Iowa), Patrick Leahy (D-Vermont), John Cornyn (R-Texas), Cory Booker (D-New Jersey and Mike Lee (R-Utah), among others. Durbin, Grassley, Leahy, and Lee have been vigorous in their demands that the BOP should do more to move the most vulnerable inmates out of prison because of COVID-19. And Booker is a co-sponsor of the Federal Correctional Facilities COVID-19 Response Act, introduced two months ago to address inadequacies in the BOP’s management of the pandemic. “The Department of Justice’ response to the COVID-19 pandemic has been unacceptable and has placed nearly 2.3 million incarcerated people in danger,” Booker said at the time.

What will the Committee ask Carvajal? Well, it could start with the Director’s past statements about the BOP’s “transparency” on COVID. Carvajal told a House subcommittee in December that “the Bureau has published one of the most detailed and thorough COVID pandemic resource areas in the federal government on our public website at www.bop.gov/coronavirus.”

timebackward210412Is that a fact, Mr. Director? Sure, since April 2020, the BOP has provided a running total of the number of inmates who tested positive for COVID. But two months ago, the total mysteriously started going down. I initially thought that Steven Hawking had been right that the universe may someday contract: maybe it has begun, and time is moving backward. But that was not the case. Instead, the BOP had adopted the view is that if an inmate contracted COVID but thereafter was released, it should be treated as though he or she had never been there. Because the inmate had never been there, then his or her COVID case could not count against the BOP’s total.

Accounting brilliance, Mr. Director! But don’t be surprised if some on the Committee might be so forward-thinking, number-wise, and wonder whether – with enough time – the Bureau’s total number of historic COVID cases might regress to zero.

What’s more, the Bureau’s loose use of the definition of “recovered” might raise Committee doubts. Last week, the BOP announced that two more “recovered” inmates, both at the Springfield, Missouri, Medical Center for Federal Inmates, had died. One, Leonard Williams, contracted COVID in late February, but “on Monday, March 22, 2021,” the BOP said, “in accordance with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidelines, Mr. Williams was converted to a status of recovered following the completion of medical isolation and presenting with no symptoms. On Saturday, April 3, 2021, Mr. Williams became unresponsive.” He was pretty unresponsive, all right. The EMT crew pronounced him dead before he got to the hospital.

Another inmate, Jaime Benavides, caught COVID in December but was declared “recovered” 10 days later. But “on Thursday, March 25, 2021, Mr. Benavides’ condition worsened and he was transported to a local hospital for further treatment and evaluation.” Committee members may how a “recovered” person’s condition can worsen. After all, he had “recovered!” Mr. Benavides died of his recovery on April 4.

numbers180327The Marshall Project has been reporting a tally of COVID in federal and state prisons every Friday for over a year. Last Friday, it informed readers that its

data no longer includes new cases from the Federal Bureau of Prisons, which has had more prisoners infected than any other system. In early March, the bureau’s totals began to drop because they removed cases of anyone who was released, a spokesman said. Similarly, in early April, the Bureau of Prisons lowered the number of deaths it was reporting among people held in private prisons. As a result, we cannot accurately determine new infections or deaths in federal prisons.

The New York Times noted last week in a report on COVID in prisons that its data were not complete because “the federal prison system and ICE did not regularly provide facility-level data for inmate infections or disclose the number of tests conducted on inmates or correctional staff members.”

Maybe the Committee will ask Carvajal about the BOP’s abysmal staff vaccination rate. Last week, the Federal News Network reported on a number of government agencies whose frontline workers were having trouble accessing vaccines. But, FNN said, “the Bureau of Prisons in the Justice Department is having the opposite problem. BOP says it offered the COVID-19 vaccine to all of its employees, but only 49% took the agency up on its offer. BOP says it can’t require employees to take the vaccine since the Food and Drug Administration hasn’t formally approved them yet.”

As of last Friday, the BOP reported only a very questionable 208 inmate COVID cases, but 1,250 sick staff, a number unchanged in the last two weeks. Committee members might justifiably wonder why the inmate number – which the BOP controls – has dropped so dramatically, while the staff number – which the BOP cannot control – remains so high.

Perhaps the Committee will want to know why the BOP touts that it had put 125,000 shots into arms as of last Friday, yet it reports only 23% of the inmate population has been vaccinated.

plagueB200406But it may just be that the Committee will be interested in some stats The New York Times ran in last week’s COVID in prisons story: Worldwide, two people out of 100 caught COVID. In the US, nine people out of 100 caught COVID. In the BOP, 39 out of 100 prisoners, although the “true count is most likely higher because of a dearth of testing.”

There’s more than Monday-morning quarterbacking to this hearing. The pandemic is not quite done. Researchers are warning that if the B.1.1.7 variant, which is more contagious, becomes more dominant, the nation could experience another peak in cases this summer that may be worse than the January peak.

It is likely that Thursday will be hamburger day for the Director. After all, Politico says he will be “grilled.”

Senate Judiciary Committee Calendar, Oversight of the Federal Bureau of Prisons

Politico, Prison chief to face congressional grilling (April 9, 2021)

S.328, Federal Correctional Facilities COVID–19 Response Act

DOJ, Statement of Michael D. Carvajal, Director Federal Bureau of Prisons (December 2, 2020)

BOP Press Release, Inmate Death at MCFP Springfield (April 7, 2021)

BOP Press Release No. 2, Inmate Death at MCFP Springfield (April 7, 2021)

The Marshall Project, A State-by-State Look at Coronavirus in Prisons (April 9, 2021)

FNN, Frontline feds facing inconsistent access to COVID vaccines (April 6, 2021)

The New York Times, Incarcerated and Infected: How the Virus Tore Through the US Prison System (April 10, 2021)

Insidenova, Spread of new COVID-19 variant may cause another peak in cases this summer, UVa researchers say (April 4, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root