Tag Archives: watanabe

Bivens, We Hardly Knew Ye… – Update for November 20, 2026

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

THE DEATH OF BIVENS, OR JUST MORE DISMEMBERMENT?

In football, a 2-12 season would be a disaster. The same ought to be true for Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics.

Congress gave people the right to sue state and local government officials who violate their constitutional rights after the Civil War in a law codified at 42 USC § 1983. No similar remedy existed for people injured by federal officials’ wrongdoing until 1971, when in Bivens, the Supreme Court gave people the right to sue the federal government for money damages when their constitutional rights are violated.

In the Bivens case, agents tossed Webster Bivens’ apartment without a search warrant, and terrorized him and his family. Since then, the Supreme Court has expanded Bivens in only two other situations. One was where a Congressman allegedly sexually harassed a staffer. The other was Carlson v. Green, a 1979 decision where the family of an inmate sued Bureau of Prisons officials who failed to provide him medical assistance during an asthma attack (from which he died). 

In 12 other cases since 1979, the Court has refused to extend Bivens protection and most recently has suggested that Bivens was wrongly decided.  It looks like Kekai Watanabe’s will be unlucky number 13.

Kekai was assaulted at the Federal Detention Center in Honolulu back in 2021, resulting in him receiving a fractured tailbone. Despite repeated complaints and requests for medical assistance, Kekai was only given acetaminophen. Seven months after the assault, the extent of his injuries was discovered in an X-ray. Bone chips from the fractured tailbone had migrated into the surrounding soft tissue, causing him intense pain that continues today.

Kekai sued BOP employees under Bivens for 8th Amendment deliberate indifference to serious medical needs. He figured that his 8th Amendment deliberate indifference fit squarely into Carlson v. Green, but some Justices last week were skeptical.

The government argued that the high court’s landmark precedents no longer provided a path for such claims. SCOTUSBlog reported, “A majority of the justices seemed poised to throw out the inmate’s lawsuit, even if it wasn’t clear whether they were ready to bar such lawsuits more broadly in the future.”

Justice Neil Gorsuch observed that the Federal Tort Claims Act was “a really good advantage when you’re a plaintiffs’ lawyer. I used to be one, and I always liked to have a deep-pocket defendant.”  Gorsuch elicited from the government’s attorney that “[i]n almost all the cases that” he had “encountered… there is an FTCA claim brought in parallel” with the claim under Carlson – in part because the standard for prevailing is lower, qualified immunity does not apply, and “[y]ou have a defendant who’s able to pay, the United States.”

Justice Samuel Alito had a similar question, asking the government’s attorney “whether Bivens in this context provides anything … of value that is not available based on other remedies.”

But not every Justice may be ready to drive a stake through Bivens’ heart. Justice Kavanaugh asked Walker how the court should handle the “fact … that Congress has had 55 years since Bivens and 46 years since Carlson to [legislatively negate them] and has not done so?” “It seems,” Kavanaugh continued, “like Congress, in fact, has left Bivens and Carlson where they stood… and Congress has operated against that backdrop.”

Chief Justice John Roberts noted that the federal government had “expressly” not asked the court to overrule Bivens in the past, “and, of course, they have broad experience in this context. And I wonder,” he asked the BOP employee’s lawyer, “if you have any insight into why or at least why shouldn’t we, on that question, defer to their expertise and experience on that question?”

Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson appeared most likely to side with Kekai. Justice Elana Kagan, on the other hand, suggested that his case involves “factual differences.” In Carlson, she said that “there was a view that the prison officials had actively contributed to the injury, and… that the prison officials knew exactly what was happening while it was happening.” Kekai’s case, by contrast, “looks like a pretty standard medical malpractice case, bad but standard, where the factual circumstances in Carlson look like something a good deal more than that.”

Expect a case further limiting Bivens on 8th Amendment claims, a decision that will impact BOP inmates the most.

Nielsen v Watanabe, Case No. 25-417 (argued November 9, 2026)

Courthouse News Service, Justices look to limit lawsuits against federal prison officials (November 9, 2026)

SCOTUSBlog, Court appears unlikely to side with inmate in lawsuit for violation of his constitutional rights (November 10, 2026)

~ Thomas L. Root