Sentencing Commission Adds Expertise to Deliberations – Update for November 16, 2026

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

ONE SMALL STEP FOR A COMMISSION, ONE GIANT LEAP FOR THE GUIDELINES

Most readers of this newsletter are too young to remember astronaut Neil Armstrong’s words when he became the first human to step onto the moon 57 years ago.

I recalled them last week when the US Sentencing Commission adopted a change in its internal procedures to include representatives from both the Criminal Law Committee of the Judicial Conference of the United States and the Federal Public and Community Defenders in the agency’s deliberative process at nonpublic meetings.

I have frequently criticized the USSC for making decisions on Guidelines changes in private meetings and trotting out the Commissioners to vote without debate in public meetings that last under 20 minutes (and would be a lot shorter but for Commission Chairman Carlton W. Reeves long-winded opening remarks (but then, he’s a federal judge, so he likes to talk). More people at the table likely leads to more debate, and that should lead to more transparency.

The decision was contentious. The 3-2 vote came over the objection of two Republican Commission members, who accused President Joe Biden’s Democratic USSC appointees of rushing through a ​change of Commission membership.

The Commission has seven voting seats, no more than four of which can be filled by those from one political party. Only five of the seats are currently filled. Three are held by Democrats — Judge Reeves and Vice Chairs Felipe Restrepo and Laura Mate — and two by Republicans — Vice Chair Claire Murray and Commissioner Candice Wong. Restrepo’s and Murray’s terms expired more than a year ago, but they continue to serve until the current Congress ends in late December.

President Trump has nominated four people to fill the two slots now open and two more that will open up at the end of December: three Republicans — US District Judge John Cronan (SDNY), White House attorney Jason Manion, Commissioner Murray — and one Democrat, Judge Restrepo (3rd Circuit). The nominations are pending on the Senate floor, and will probably be approved in the next few weeks.

Last year, the Commission formed a committee of former prisoners to advise on Commission policymaking and allowed outside experts to participate in USSC research. Letting outside “stakeholders” – to use a favored government buzzword – into the Commission’s nonpublic meetings is an additional “effort… to examine and improve its internal policymaking,” the Commission said in a press release.

Most vexing is that important issues such as changes in the methamphetamine Guidelines are proposed and disappear without so much as a vote or a dissent or even a peep.

“Inviting our colleagues within the judiciary into the room is a simple, common-sense fix that has garnered overwhelming support from across the criminal justice system,” Judge Reeves said.

Wong, a former federal prosecutor now in private practice, complained that “no commission has ever seen fit to add more de facto ex officio members where Congress did not and has not.”

She noted that Sen Charles Grassley (R-IA), outgoing ​chairman of the Senate Judiciary ​Committee, opposed ⁠the proposal, which she called “an end run around Congress’s clear intent.”

While by law ​a member of the US Dept of Justice has long served as a non-voting commission member, no such position exists for the public defender community.

Murray questioned the unusual and hasty November vote, saying ⁠it had been rushed to get ahead of likely Senate confirmation of the new members, which will tip Commission control to Republicans.

“Today is the very last day that the commissioners voting for this amendment could be sure that their votes alone would be sufficient to carry the ​day,” Murray said.

Writing in his Sentencing Law and Policy blog last week, Ohio State University law professor Doug Berman said, “Interestingly, the press release calls this vote ‘a more transparent, inclusive, and effective process for making federal sentencing policy.’ Still, it does not indicate the vote tally for its decision today or indicate when or how it might be ‘evaluating the additional Rules revisions it proposed earlier this year.’ Oh well.”

USSC, United States Sentencing Commission Votes to Expand Consultation with Key Stakeholders in Federal Sentencing System (November 13, 2026)

USSC, US Sentencing Commission votes to expand role of key stakeholders in “the agency’s deliberative process at nonpublic meetings” (November 13, 2026)

Reuters, Divided US sentencing panel votes to give public defenders role in policymaking (November 13, 2026)

Sentencing Matters Substack, The Sentencing Commission’s Choice: Unravel, or Make the Case for the Second Step Act (November 9, 2026)

~ Thomas L. Root

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *