We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
YOU’RE DOING SO WELL, YOU NEED MORE SUPERVISED RELEASE
Victor Grandy was swept up by the Feds 30 years ago for drug trafficking and was sentenced to mandatory life in prison. After the First Step Act passed in 2018, his judge cut his sentence to 360 months. Vic walked out of prison in 2019 and began a mandatory 10-year supervised release term.
As the 9th Circuit described it last week, “While on supervised release, Grandy has been a model citizen. He has a stable residence. He is gainfully employed. He volunteers at a local food pantry. He has fully complied with all the conditions of his supervised release. And, notably, Grandy is a rising artist who is committed to pursuing a professional career in art. Upon his release from prison, Grandy apprenticed for a renowned painter before becoming an artist himself in multiple media, including drawing, painting, and sculpting. In June 2024, a Los Angeles gallery discovered Grandy and invited him to present a solo show. Since then, Grandy’s profile has grown considerably: His artwork is collected internationally, and he has exhibited at group and solo shows across the United States. But due to the conditions of his supervised release, Grandy cannot travel for his own shows—at least, not freely.”
In February 2025, Vic moved for early termination of his supervised release under 18 USC § 3583(e), based on his successful reintegration and to give him freedom to travel for his art career. The district court denied the motion, holding that the law did not allow early termination of a mandatory minimum supervised release term and that Vic had not shown extraordinary reasons for granting his motion. Without any notice to the parties, the court relied on a 2022 Sentencing Commission study and an outdated version of the Administrative Office of US Courts (AOUSC) Guide to Judiciary Policy. The judge misinterpreted the 2022 Study as saying that three-fourths of drug traffickers were rearrested before the end of the imposed supervision term and applied the outdated AOUSC Guide’s recommendation that probation officers consider nine factors when weighing a motion for early termination of supervised release.
Finally, the district court reasoned that Vic’s success on supervised release demonstrated his continued need for supervision because it was working so well.
Huh?
Last week, the 9th Circuit resoundingly rejected the district court’s holding. A district court has a lot of discretion in granting early termination, the appellate court ruled, but it abuses its discretion “if its conclusions are without support in inferences that may be drawn from the facts in the record… [or when it] rests its decision on clearly erroneous findings of fact.” Here, the district court misread the 2022 study, which found only that three-fourths of marijuana offenders – not drug offenders in general – were rearrested prior to the end of their supervised release terms.
What was worse, the district judge ignored a new 2025 AOUSC policy in effect when it denied Vic’s motion. The new policy replaced the old standard with a recommendation that probation officers apply a presumption in favor of early termination when individuals under supervision satisfy six criteria. Under the current guidance, after eighteen months, even “higher risk persons under supervision who have demonstrated a reduction in risk… and who are in substantial compliance” with the enumerated criteria “must be considered for early termination.”
The Circuit was especially critical of the district judge’s pretzel logic that Vic’s success while on supervised release was a reason to continue supervised release. The 9th held that “[u]nder the current guidance, an individual’s success while on supervised release should weigh in favor of early termination—not against it… The district court’s approach strands individuals like Vic in a Catch-22: The more they demonstrate their successful reintegration, the less likely they are to obtain early termination of their supervised release… This does not follow.”
The Circuit remanded the case, telling the district court to expedite the decision before Vic’s 10-year term ended.
United States v. Grandy, Case No. 25-4491, 2026 U.S.App. LEXIS 34645 (9th Cir. November 12, 2026)
~ Thomas L. Root