We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
JUST A COVID LULL?
The BOP’s official inmate COVID numbers continued to fall last week, ending Friday at 95 ill inmates, a 34% decrease from the week before. Ominously, however, staff cases increased by 4% to 263. COVID remains in 92 facilities, down only two from a week before.
But in the last few days, things have turned around (and not in a good way). As of last night, 107 inmates were ill, 258 staff were sick, and COVID was present in 100 facilities (82% of all BOP prisons).
The BOP reported one additional inmate death last week, but it was from last July (and apparently escaped the Bureau’s notice). Ruben Castillo, who had had COVID before he arrived at the BOP, died of what the Bureau said were “post-COVID cardiac complications.” Yet the courts and government continue to argue that inmates who have had COVID don’t face any continuing risks.
As of last Friday, 70.2% of inmates were vaccinated. But with the November 22 deadline for BOP staff vaccinations now having passed, only 65.7% have gotten the shot, according to BOP statistics, up just 1.3 points from last week. This compares to a systemwide vax rate of 90% for federal workers.
So those noncompliant BOP staffers will be fired now, right?
Well, that was the story once. But now, the punishment has gone from 40 lashes with a cat-o’nine-tails to 30 lashes with a soggy spaghetti noodle. NBC reports that “for those who haven’t met the requirement or requested a medical or religious exemption, the federal government will continue an “education and counseling process, followed by additional enforcement steps over time if needed’,” quoting a White House official.
White House press secretary Jen Psaki said the administration doesn’t “anticipate facing any governmental operational disruptions due to [the vaccine] requirement and in fact, the requirement will avoid disruptions, in our view, in our labor force because vaccinations help avoid COVID.”
The U.S. reported a seven-day average of nearly 95,000 new COVID infections last Thursday, up 31% over the past two weeks. “I’ve been predicting a pretty bad winter wave again, and it looks like it’s starting to happen,” Peter Hotez, the dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine, said last week. “There’s just too many unvaccinated and too many partially vaccinated [people].”
That “too many” number apparently includes inmates, too. Although a much larger percentage of federal inmates have been jabbed than staff, a former prisoner-turned-writer for Biz News last week argued that opposition by prison staffs to “vaccine mandates highlights an illogical situation that has developed with little discussion: To date, neither the federal government nor any state or municipality has officially mandated the jab for their incarcerated populations. That doesn’t make sense: Prisoners, who are at higher risk for infection and death than corrections officers, aren’t required to get vaccinated while corrections officers, who are at lower risk, are being told they must get vaccinated.”
Expect more of those arguments. In New York City, where the mayor has ordered all city corrections staff to be vaccinated, union chief Benny Boscio complained last week that “it is extremely hypocritical to mandate our officers be vaccinated, while there is no mandate for the inmates in our custody…”
Except where the mandate neither has teeth nor much effect.
BOP, Inmate Death at FCI Stafford (November 17, 2021)
CNBC, Covid cases rise yet again in U.S. ahead of Thanksgiving holiday (November 19, 2021)
The Hill, Experts predict an alarming surge of US COVID-19 cases this winter (November 18, 2021)
NBC News, Administration expects 95% compliance with federal worker vaccine mandate (November 23, 2021)
Washington Post, Federal workers can be fired for refusing vaccination, but must show up to work until their cases are determined, new guidance says (September 17, 2021)
Stat News, Vaccine mandates should cover the incarcerated, too, not just prison guards and workers (November 18, 2021)
Corrections1, NYC correction officers refusing to get COVID shots despite looming mandate (November 17, 2021)
– Thomas L. Root