We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

THE DEFINITION OF FUTILITY

People seeking compassionate release know that 18 USC § 3582(c)(1)(A) requires that they exhaust administrative remedies first, that is, ask the warden of their facility to recommend that the BOP bring the motion on their behalf and then wait 30 days before filing.

Many prisoners have asked courts to waive the exhaustion requirement as being futile. Courts have uniformly refused, ruling – like the 6th Circuit did last June in United States v. Alam, that the exhaustion requirement “ensures that the prison administrators can prioritize the most urgent claims. And it ensures that they can investigate the gravity of the conditions supporting compassionate release and the likelihood that the conditions will persist. These are not interests we should lightly dismiss or re-prioritize.”

The courts’ confidence in the Bureau of Prisons would be laughable if the stakes were not so high. And a report last week from NBC and The Marshall Project underscores what attorneys, inmates, advocates and experts have long suspected: since March 1, wardens have denied or ignored over 98% of all compassionate release requests.

Of the 10,940 federal prisoners who applied for compassionate release in just the first two months of the pandemic, from March through May, wardens approved 1.4%, or 156. Some wardens, including those at Seagoville and Oakdale, did not respond to any request during those two months, while others deny every request presented to them. Of the 156 approved by wardens, only 11 were approved by the Central Office. Overall approval rate? One-tenth of one percent.

Here’s the breakdown: 84.8% of the requests were denied by wardens. Another 13.7% were not even answered.

In other words, you have literally a one-in-a-thousand chance that the BOP will approve a compassionate release request. This is about the same as an inmate’s chance of dying from COVID-19 (0.09%). On the other hand, 16,000 people have received compassionate release (slightly more than 1% of the BOP population).

Notable pullouts from the data: At Elkton, an early COVID hot spot (with more than 900 cases and nine deaths), the warden denied 866 out of 867 requests for compassionate release. At FCI Terminal Island, 694 prisoners had tested positive by the end of May, the warden approved five of the 256 compassionate release requests filed between March and May.

A BOP spokesman told The Marshall Project that “we can share that the BOP has continued to process compassionate release requests as directed by the First Step Act and agency policy.”

United States v. Alam, 960 F.3d 831 (6th Cir. 2020)

NBC News/The Marshall Project, Thousands of Sick Federal Prisoners Sought Compassionate Release. 98 Percent Were Denied. (October 7, 2020)

Rochester, Minnesota, Post-Bulletin, Cases Continue in Federal Prison, Compassionate Release Hard to Get (Oct 9)

– Thomas L. Root