We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

THE BOP’S TERRIBLE, HORRIBLE, NO GOOD, VERY BAD DAY

Tuesday, November 19, was no kind of day for the BOP.

First, two BOP correctional officers on duty the morning financier Jeffrey Epstein, in pretrial detention for sex charges, killed himself last summer were indicted under 18 USC 1001 for having faked records that they performed Special Housing Unit inmate counts overnight and one count of conspiracy to defraud the United States for good measure. The New York Times reported one CO was catching up on sports news and looking at motorcycle sales on a government computer, while the other spent time shopping online for furniture. For a couple hours, they slept.

Attorney General William Barr said the suicide was the result of “a perfect storm of screw-ups,” numerous irregularities at MDC New York that gave Epstein the chance to take his own life.

At the same time the indictments were being announced, BOP director Kathleen Hawk Sawyer got grilled by the Senate Judiciary Committee about the Epstein debacle, a mess she was brought out of retirement to fix. She admitted that issues such as officers sleeping on the job have been an ongoing problem. “We’ve been monitoring the cameras… at every one of our institutions to determine how well and how effective our staff members are doing their rounds,” Sawyer said. “We have found a couple of other instances [of guards napping on the job] and we’ve immediately referred those to the inspector general’s office.”

Sawyer also told the Committee that FBI investigators are looking into whether a “criminal enterprise” may have played a role in Epstein’s death.

The Committee also criticized the proposed PATTERN risk assessment tool which is to be adopted in its final form by the end of November. Sen. Richard Durbin (D-Illinois) complained that PATTERN is “so fundamentally unfair, that it cannot stand without challenge.”

In a PATTERN test run, Durbin said, 29% of white inmates were deemed to be high-risk for returning to prison compared with 59% of black inmates. “Part of the problem is the tool doesn’t distinguish between a traffic stop and a murder conviction,” Durbin said. “It simply measures the risk that someone will be arrested or return to the federal system, and an arrest is not a new crime. A conviction is a new crime.”

The New York Times, Guards Accused of Napping and Shopping Online the Night Epstein Died (Nov. 19)

The Crime Report, Federal Prison Guard Napping Called Ongoing Problem (Nov. 20)

Associated Press, AG Barr: Epstein’s death was a ‘perfect storm of screw-ups’ (Nov. 22)

– Thomas L. Root