Dept. of Low Expectations – Update for October 8, 2019

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

ONE BILL GETS REPORTED FROM ONE COMMITTEE, AND EVERYONE THINKS HE’S GOING HOME

release191008A few readers complained last week that I had not reported the House Judiciary Committee’s vote that sent H.R. 4018 to the House floor. H.R. 4018 is a bill that would modify the Elderly Offender Home Detention Program (34 USC § 60541(g)(5)) to let those over-60 year old prisoners qualify for home detention after doing two-thirds of their net sentence rather than their gross sentence.

Currently, to qualify for the First Step Act’s expanded EOHD program, you must be 60 years old and have served two-thirds of your whole sentence. In other words, if you were sentenced to 100 months, you have to serve 67 months before you go home on home detention, and then you stay in detention until you reach 85 months, when you are released.

H.R. 4018, a single-sponsor bill, would qualify a 60-year old prisoner after he or she did two thirds of the net sentence. If you were sentenced to 100 months, you get out after 85 months with good time. H.R. 4018 would put you in the EOHD with two thirds of 85 months. Thus, you would go home after 57 months, and stay on home detention until 85 months.

longodds191008The House Judiciary Committee reported the bill favorably on Sept. 10 by a 28-8 vote. Nevertheless, Skopos Labs – which tracks federal legislation – gives the bill a 3% chance of becoming law. The legislation, with only 10 House co-sponsors, had little chance of being brought up for a Senate vote even before the impeachment talk ramped up. Recall how the First Step Act, with the House passing a very pro-prisoner version, barely made it to the Senate floor. That bill, with over 40 Senate co-sponsors and President Trump lobbying for passage, finally passed as a well watered-down measure in the closing hours of the Senate.

I did not mention H.R. 4018 for the same reason I did not mention the proposed Prohibiting Punishment of Acquitted Conduct Act of 2019, introduced Sept. 26 by Senators Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and Dick Durbin (D-Illinois). The bill would prohibit federal courts from considering acquitted conduct at sentencing, defining ‘acquitted conduct’ to include “acts for which a person was criminally charged and adjudicated not guilty after trial in a Federal, State, Tribal, or Juvenile court, or acts underlying a criminal charge or juvenile information dismissed upon a motion for acquittal.”

Grassley, who is Senate president pro tempore, said, “If any American is acquitted of charges by a jury of their peers, then some sentencing judge shouldn’t be able to find them guilty anyway and add to their punishment.” Currently, the Guidelines are written to run up the sentence with acquitted conduct, and judges do it all the time.

mcconnell180219This bill, S.2566, already has five co-sponsors, two Democrats and three Republicans. Grassley has a lot of horsepower in the Senate leadership. Yet, like H.R. 4018, it has no more than a ghost of a chance of passage. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Kentucky), controls what bills reach the Senate floor for a vote. He has been an opponent of any prison reform, and only brought First Step to a vote because of White House pressure. Now, with President Trump soured on criminal justice legislation and preoccupied with re-election and impeachment, there won’t be any White House support for bringing any criminal justice measure to a Senate vote.

Stories like this don’t help: Last Friday, the Providence, Rhode Island, Journal reported that Joel Francisco, released from a life sentence for crack because of the First Step Act, is wanted for stabbing a man to death in a hookah bar. Remember Wendell Callahan? The Sen. Tom Cottons (R-Arkansas) of the world are always gleeful to have a poster child against sentencing reform like this fall into their laps.

H.R.4018 – To provide that the amount of time that an elderly offender must serve before being eligible for placement in home detention is to be reduced by the amount of good time credits earned by the prisoner (reported favorably by House Judiciary Committee, Sept. 10)

S. 2566: A bill to amend section 3661 of title 18, United States Code, to prohibit the consideration of acquitted conduct at sentencing (Introduced Sept. 26)

Providence, Rhode Island, Journal, He was released early from prison in February. Now he’s wanted for a murder on Federal Hill (Oct. 4)

– Thomas L. Root

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *