We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
UNPAID BOP WORKERS CLAIM THAT INMATES HAVE IT SWEET TURNS OUT TO BE “FAKE NEWS”
NBC News reported last Sunday that the partial government shutdown that continues without an end in sight has “created a delicious irony at federal prisons — inmates dining on lavish holiday meals in front of disgruntled staffers forced to work without pay.”
Several BOP food service employees complained to NBC News that the Christmas and New Year’s Day meals inmates traditionally receive “aggravate[ed] staffers who were already fretting about bills to pay and children to feed.: The report cited steak and shrimp served Jan. 1 at FCI Pekin, Cornish hen and Boston creme pie at MDC Brooklyn, and “heaping plates of chicken wings” served at an unidentified federal prison in Minnesota.
“You’re giving a gift to somebody who committed a crime, but yet you won’t pay the people who are supervising them?” NBC quoted a food service foreman at FMC Rochester complaining. “It’s frustrating and maddening.” In addition to working without pay, many of the prison staffers, including correctional officers, were ordered to cut vacations short or face a loss in wages and possible administrative punishment, including suspensions.
Well, it turns out that the “several BOP food service employees” who complained were part of a well-orchestrated union campaign, one the news outlets swallowed hook, line and sinker. Reason.com reported on Monday that in order “to make themselves look like the victims in this government shutdown, union officials shopped around a story to multiple media outlets about criminals being treated like kings while prison guards have to freelance as Uber drivers.” Reason said
It’s a bit amazing (and disappointing) how many outlets ran with this tale in exactly the form union reps likely preferred. Over at USA Today, Kevin Johnson described these meals as a “display of culinary largesse.” Cleve Wootson, Jr., at The Washington Post called it an example of the “hypocritical” or “ironic” moments of the federal shutdown. NBC called it a “delicious irony” that unpaid staffers had to feed “fancy” food to the inmates. Characterizing this series of parallel-but-unrelated events as a role reversal suggests that we should be treating prisoners poorly. The reporters can take solace in knowing that, generally, we do.
Adding to the staffers’ bitter feelings, NBC News said, “the working inmates were still drawing government paychecks for their prison jobs, which include painting buildings, cooking meals and mowing lawns.”
NBC News, Hard to digest: Inmates eat holiday steak during shutdown while prison workers go unpaid (Jan. 6)
Reason.com, Prison Guards Orchestrate Media Campaign To Complain About Inmates Getting Edible Food for Christmas (Jan. 7)
– Thomas L. Root