Tag Archives: second step act

EQUAL Act But Unequal Reform? – Update for April 21, 2022

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

EQUAL ACT MAY BE ALL WE GET

Congress was recessed all last week and for part of this one, so no legislative progress was made on the EQUAL Act (S.79), the MORE Act (H.R. 3617), or – for that matter – anything else. But nothing can stop politicians from talking, even during vacations.

crack-coke200804The good news is that all of the talk about EQUAL – which makes crack sentences equal to cocaine powder sentences – suggests it has the support for passage. The only question is when Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) will bring it up for a vote. While the Judiciary Committee held a hearing on the crack-cocaine disparity bill last year, it has yet to schedule a markup.

The bad news is everything else. Politico ran an analysis last week reporting that Sens Richard Durbin (D-IL) and Charles Grassley (R-IA), the top Democrat and Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, are still talking about a merger of bills such as the First Step Implementation Act (S.1014), the Smarter Sentencing Act (S.1013), and the COVID-19 Safer Detention Act (S. 312) into a single narrow follow-up bill amending the First Step Act, Durbin and Grassley are calling a Second Step Act. 

“But both senior senators acknowledge it’s not a glide path forward,” Politico said, “particularly given the GOP messaging on rising crime ahead of the 2022 midterms — a focus that was on full display during Ketanji Brown Jackson’s Supreme Court hearings last month.”

Jackson was blasted last month by a few Republican senators for being too soft on sentencing child sex abuse and drug offenders. “One of the most important consequences of these confirmation hearings is there are district judges across the country who may have ambitions for elevations,” Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX), who led the charge against Judge Jackson, told CNN. Any judges looking for future promotions “are going to think twice about letting violent criminals go or giving them a slap on the wrist, rather than following the law and imposing serious sentences for those who have committed serious crimes.”

snake220421[Editor’s note: While it is correct that Cruz has been described by one conservative columnist as being “like a serpent covered in Vaseline” who “treats the American people like two-bit suckers in 10-gallon hats,”  some maintain that there are good snakes in Texas (but Sen. Cruz is not on their list).]

Far from the only effect, the Jackson hearings have also “dampened the interest in doing what we call the Second Step Act, but we’re still seeing what can be worked out,” Grassley said in a brief interview. He added that if Democrats agree to certain provisions related to law enforcement, “that might make it possible to get something done.”

Meanwhile, Durbin said he’s concerned about a Second Step Act’s prospects for passage, ‘particularly given Republican accusations during Jackson’s confirmation hearings that the justice-in-waiting was soft on crime. The Judiciary chair ranked criminal justice as high on his list of priorities, though he said legislation addressing crime and law enforcement “may be just as challenging as immigration” — a famously tough area of bipartisan compromise on Capitol Hill.

Durbin and Grassley both think a Second Step Act is needed to implement sentencing changes in the First Step law by making them retroactive, midterms are coming up in a little more than 6 months and “campaign-season politics surrounding criminal justice reform threaten broader GOP support. While some lonely voices are calling for passage of such a bill, with Democrats in control of the White House and both houses of Congress, expect a cacophony of Republicans claims that Democrats are to blame for rising crime rates. That should make sentencing changes that much harder, Politico said.

Senate aides on both sides of the aisle warn that EQUAL could still face a challenging path to final passage, including a potentially arduous debate over amendments. Republicans who oppose the bill would almost certainly want to force vulnerable Senate Democrats to take tough amendment votes amid reports of rising violent crime in major cities and the approaching November election. Even Grassley, who is not a co-sponsor but is unapologetically pro-reform, has outlined concerns about whether EQUAL could garner enough Republican support in the Senate to pass.

cotton190502So the climate for criminal justice reform is getting ugly. Once, only Sen Tom Cotton (R-Ark) (who calls First Step Trump’s biggest mistake) demanded longer sentences. Last week, mainstream Newsweek magazine ran an opinion piece claiming that “America, in the year 2022, does not suffer from an over-incarceration problem. On the contrary, we suffer from an under-incarceration problem.” The column called on Congress to end “the jailbreak of slashed sentences and the broader civilizational suicide of the ‘criminal justice reform’.”

Politico, Criminal justice reform faces political buzzsaw as GOP hones its midterm message (April 14, 2022)

Politico, What’s next for criminal justice reform? (April 14, 2022)

CNN, Ambitious trial judges could be wary after GOP attacks on Judge Jackson’s sentencing record (April 11, 2022)

Wichita Eagle, Former U.S. attorney tells how criminal justice could be more just (April 12, 2022)

EQUAL Act (S.79)

First Step Implementation Act (S.1014)

Smarter Sentencing Act (S.1013)

COVID-19 Safer Detention Act (S. 312)

MORE Act, (H.R.3617)

– Thomas L. Root

Dog Bites Man: Congress Expected to Do Nothing on Criminal Justice Reform This Session – Update for May 23, 2019

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

CONGRESS POISED TO DO NOTHING ON JUSTICE REFORM UNTIL AFTER 2020

The media are already buzzing about the 4,000+ expected releases from federal prison after July 19, when the seven-days-per-year extra good time awarded in the First Step Act is scheduled to be effective.

grid160411The Washington Examiner wrote last week that “Trump’s potentially contradictory impulses for law and order but also second chances face a looming political test when about 4,000 federal inmates are released in July under an expansion of “good time” credit in the First Step Act, which he signed in December. Reform advocates say successful reentry into society for the looming wave must be assured. Otherwise, the reform cause and its political backers, including Trump, could be damaged.”

The immediate release wave had been expected right when the bill passed on Dec. 21. But as the Examiner put it, a “drafting error placed the good time credit expansion — allowing an extra seven days a year — in an unrelated section of the law featuring a seven-month delay.”

mcconnell180219While Congress may be watching to see how the releasees do, it will not be acting on any criminal justice reform itself. It is clear that nothing the Democratic-run House of Representatives may pass is even going to come to a vote in the Senate. In Saturday’s Wall Street Journal, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Kentucky) made it clear that the Republican-led Senate will block anything Senate or House Democrats want. “Meanwhile, the Democrats are divided,” the Journal said. “House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer tout their legislative agenda, but half or more of their followers would rather rough up President Trump and then impeach him.”

Some of the Democrats running for president are touting criminal justice reforms as part of their platforms, but neither the candidates nor their opponents are interested in seeing anything enacted before the election.

With some of the 25-odd Democrats announced for president including strong criminal justice proposals in their platforms, it is unlikely the Senate would hand any of them a victory by passing any criminal justice reform measure.

Washington Examiner, Trump embrace of criminal reform faces test as 4,000 inmates near release (May 17)

Wall Street Journal, Mitch McConnell on Judges and the ‘Graveyard’ (May 18)

– Thomas L. Root

Fake News on Second Step Act – Update for May 2, 2019

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

JUST FOOLIN’

trumpaprilfool190502President Trump told an April Fools’ Day gathering the White House to celebrate the First Step Act that “I’m announcing that the Second Step Act will be focused on successful reentry and reduced unemployment for Americans with past criminal records, and that’s what we’re starting right away.”

Um… not really.

The Washington Examiner last week quoted White House sources as saying that “there’s definitely not a Second Step Act.” In fact, it appears that Trump wandered off script from the prepared speech, which did not mention a Second Step at all.

Instead, the source is quoted as saying, the White House is focused instead on implementing the First Step Act in a way that denies ammunition to opponents such as uber-critic Sen. Tom Cotton, R-Ark.

cotton190502So far, First Step has not been a roaring success. A drafting error stalled additional “good time” credit for 150,000 federal inmates, creating a likely wave of about 4,000 releases around July. White House officials considered options to move forward the date but ultimately did not. “There’s a lot of concern that they have to get this right. Folks like Tom Cotton are just waiting for someone to do something stupid,” said the source who has worked on White House efforts. “People are going to want to wait and see how this [First Step Act] works out.”

Meanwhile, a broad coalition of groups is pushing for repeal of the federal ban on Pell Grants for incarcerated students, as talks heat up over reauthorization of the Higher Education Act. Those organizations include civil rights groups, religious colleges and conservative organizations, argue that college access for students behind bars is an issue of equity for postsecondary education and also the logical extension of efforts to end mass incarceration.

Since 1994, federal law has prohibited prisoners from receiving Pell Grants, the primary form of need-based student aid. The Trump administration, however, has named financial aid for incarcerated students as a top priority for a new higher ed law.

Washington Examiner, Trump declared he was working on a Second Step Act. The proposal doesn’t exist (Apr. 26)

Inside Higher Ed, The Case for Pell in Prisons (Apr. 22)

– Thomas L. Root

After Partying Last Week, First Step Finally Gets Down to Business – Update for April 9, 2019

Leave a comment

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

FIRST STEP CELEBRATED, BUT WORRIES OVER IMPLEMENTATION REMAIN

Amid questions by some critics about the Administration’s support for the First Step Act, the Dept. of Justice’s National Institute of Justice (NIJ) yesterday announced the selection of the Hudson Institute to host the Independent Review Committee mandated by the Act to develop and implement risk and needs assessment tools and evidence-based recidivism reduction programs for the Bureau of Prisons.

firststepB180814“The Department of Justice is committed to implementing the First Step Act,” a DOJ press release quoted Attorney General William Barr as saying. “The Independent Review Committee plays an important role in that effort by assisting in the development of a new risk and needs assessment system and improvements to our recidivism reduction programming.”

NIJ also announced that it is contracting with outside researchers, including Grant Duwe, Ph.D., Zachary Hamilton Ph.D., and Angela Hawken Ph.D., for  consultation on the DOJ’s development of the risk and needs assessment system under the Act.  Dr. Duwe is the Director of Research for the Minnesota Department of Corrections, and an expert on the development of recidivism risk assessment systems. Dr. Hamilton is an Associate Professor of Criminal Justice and Criminology and the Director of the Washington State Institute for Criminal Justice, and focuses on treatment matching through risk and needs assessment systems. Dr. Hawken is a Professor of Public Policy at the New York University Marron Institute, and is the founder and director of New York University’s Litmus/BetaGov program, which assists in the development and validation of data-driven policies.

The announcement comes on the heels of last week’s White House  “First Step Act Celebration,” which was intended to bring attention to a rare piece of bipartisan legislation President Trump passed last year, and which he plans to highlight on the campaign trail. He also announced plans for a “Second Step Act,” focused on easing employment barriers for formerly incarcerated people.

“We are proving we’re a nation that believes in redemption,” Trump said, describing the “second step” legislation as featuring a $88 million funding request for prisoner social reentry programs. “The ‘Second Step Act’ will be focused on successful reentry and reduced unemployment for Americans with past criminal records, and that’s what we’re starting right away.”

“As president, I pledged to work with both parties for the good of the whole nation,” Mr. Trump said at the East Room gathering, pointing to the legislation as an example of bipartisan work that he said was “so important to me.”

But even as they danced at the White House, several observers expressed skepticism that the now-passed bill will enjoy the Administration’s full support.

money160118The Administration’s budget, released last month, listed only $14 million to pay for the First Step Act’s programs. The law specifically asked for $75 million a year for five years, beginning in 2019. The Office of Management and Budget, however, noted that the bill passed after the budget had already been finalized, and that the White House intended to revisit First Step Act funding.

Ensuring that First Step is adequately funded is crucial to its effectiveness, said Nancy La Vigne of the Urban Institute. “We always recognized that without proper funding, the First Step Act is really nothing more than window dressing,” she said.

Mr. Trump said that “my administration intends to fully fund and implement this historic law.”  On Apr. 2, the White House announced Trump will ask Congress for $147 million to implement First Step, far above the $14 million in the original budget.

risky-business-4fea6b87b70a6First Step requires development of a risk and needs assessment tool to assess inmates and determine what types of programs reduce recidivism and the incentives they would receive. The Dept. of Justice missed the Jan. 21 deadline for forming the committee tasked with developing the risk assessment standard, instead starting the committee formation process only yesterday. The Crime Report said last Monday, “It’s not clear whether the government will meet the July deadline for developing the system.”

Kevin Ring, president of Families Against Mandatory Minimums, says there hasn’t been much clarity from the administration on the status of these measures.

“All the timelines were ambitious, so it’s not surprising that they haven’t met them all,” Ring said. “It’s just it seems to be a bit of a black box. We don’t know what’s taking so long.”

The New York Times today observed that

Putting the law into practice quickly became complicated. The government partly shut down one day after Congress passed the bill and sent it to President Trump to sign into law, and many of the Justice Department employees who would have worked to fulfill it went on furlough. The shutdown, the longest in history, lasted through the end of January.

That has given law enforcement officials just over two months to start carrying out a complicated piece of legislation, a senior Justice Department official said in defending their pace… The criminal justice overhaul was also passed during intense tumult at the top of the Justice Department, which oversees the Bureau of Prisons and would be responsible for carrying out much of the new legislation.

The New York Times, Justice Dept. Works on Applying Sentencing Law as Critics Point to Delays (Apr. 9)

Hudson Institute, Hudson Institute To Host First Step Act’s Independent Review Committee (Apr. 8)

Washington Examiner, Trump announces Second Step Act to help ex-prisoners find work (Apr. 1)

The Crime Report, As White House Celebrates First Step Act, Inmate Risk-Assessment Tool Lags (Apr. 1)

The New York Times, Trump Celebrates Criminal Justice Overhaul Amid Doubts It Will Be Fully Funded (Apr. 1)

NPR, 3 Months Into New Criminal Justice Law, Success For Some And Snafus For Others (Apr. 1)

– Thomas L. Root