FCI Estill | Legal Information Services Associates LLC

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

BOP HAS ANOTHER TOUGH NEWS WEEK

I Love New York: The Dept. of Justice announced last Thursday that the Bureau of Prisons will “temporarily” close the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York, the high-rise jail near the Federal Courthouse in lower Manhattan.

The decrepit facility, described by the New York Daily News as “dysfunctional,” has been a headline-generating public relations disaster for the BOP in the past several years.

renovate210830 The closure was described as being temporary, reminiscent of restaurant “closed for renovation” announcements to mask abandonment of the premises. Indeed, the Daily News said, “Sources were skeptical the jail would ever resume operations resembling previous years, when it held 700 or more inmates.”

The decision to close comes weeks after Deputy Attorney General Lisa O. Monaco inspected the facility “given ongoing concerns,” as the DOJ said at the time.

The New York Times reported that MCC has been criticized “by inmates, lawyers and even judges for the conditions in which prisoners have been held.” It’s the prison where two COs were indicted for lying after celebrity prisoner Jeffrey Epstein, who was facing sex-trafficking charges, was found dead in his cell in August 2019 in what was ruled a suicide. In early 2020, a handgun was found in the jail during a shakedown.

In January, the facility received its fourth warden in less than two years. As the coronavirus took hold, MCC employees weren’t able to get masks and staff restrooms ran out of soap because employees charged with refilling the dispensers were pressed into duty as COs due to staff shortages. In May 2020, a court-authorized inspection found that inmates with COVID symptoms were ignored and social distancing was almost nonexistent.

Earlier this year, the MCC “was rocked by allegations that an inmate whose lawyer says he has the mental capacity of an 8-year-old child was left in a holding cell for 24 hours while awaiting a competency evaluation,” Associated Press reported. “Around the same time, a correctional officer at the facility had also reported sexual misconduct by a superior, which officials at the jail delayed reporting to senior BOP officials.”

“The MCC has been a longstanding disgrace,” New York Federal Public Defender David Patton told the Times. “It’s cramped, dark and unsanitary. The building is falling apart. Chronic shortages of medical staff mean that people suffer for long periods of time when they have urgent medical issues.” But, Mr. Patton added, MDC Brooklyn (across the river from the MCC) has many of the same problems, and if the MCC prisoners are sent there without those problems being addressed, “this move will accomplish nothing.”

Most of the 263 inmates at the MCC will be moved to MDC Brooklyn, according to Courthouse News Service, which many may seem as “out of the frying pan and into the fire.” MDC Brooklyn, where a power outage and BOP management prevarications made the news in January 2020, is still embroiled in a lawsuit brought by the NY Federal Public Defender accusing the BOP of “false statements and stonewalling” by “refusing to provide detailed or accurate information about the conditions at MDC” during the power outage. The district court in which the suit is being heard has appointed former US Attorney General Loretta Lynch as mediator in the case.

You may recall that last April, US District Court Judge Colleen McMahon said that both MCC and MDC are “run by morons.” During a sentencing proceeding, McMahon castigated the BOP, saying the agency’s ineptitude and failure to “do anything meaningful” at the two facilities amounted to the “single thing in the five years that I was chief judge of this court that made me the craziest.”

Lynch said Friday her team has been conducting “stress tests” at MDC Brooklyn to better understand problems there, such as how to improve scheduling of in-person visits. She said the BOP and inmates should anticipate that moving additional prisoners to the Brooklyn facility will “create its own ‘stress test,’ separate and apart from the ones that we have been using,” she said.

Southern Comfort: Meanwhile, Forbes published a piece last Monday describing the horrific conditions at what is left of FCI Estill after the prison was damaged by a tornado nearly 18 months ago. About 1,000 medium-security prisoners were relocated, but 66 minimum-security inmates remain, having been moved into the medium-security facility. “When the Campers arrived at the FCI, floors were covered in water, urine and feces,” Forbes reported. “Toilets were clogged, black mold and mildew could be seen throughout the facility. The vents were filthy and covered in black soot. Debris from the remaining infrastructure hung from the ceiling. Medications were suspended to inmates and anxiety ran high over COVID-19 outbreaks. The only hope for these remaining inmates was that these conditions would be short-lived and some normalcy to prison life would return. However, not much has changed in the 16 months since and these men still live in inhumane conditions.”

While the inmate count fell by 95%, “the staffing level of the facility has remained roughly the same as it was prior to the tornado (approximately 221).” That would seem to be 221 employees who could be used elsewhere…

Take This Job and Shove It: Is it any wonder BOP employees are quitting in droves? That’s the question Business Insider asked last week. “About 3,700 staffers left the BOP from March 2020 to July 3, 2021, according to agency data… That translates to the equivalent of more than 8.4 employees departing every day during that period… Current departure numbers are even more striking because the overall number of BOP employees isn’t going up — it’s going down. In 2015, there were 37,258 employees, according to a Government Accountability Office analysis of the agency’s employment data. By 2017, that number dropped to 35,569. In 2019, it stood at 34,857.”

So much for the BOP’s much-ballyhooed hiring initiative…

The COVID-19 pandemic and augmentation have increasingy strained prison workers, which could cause more prison workers to quit as staffing conditions continue to erode, union representatives told Business Insider. “I was mentally stressed out and physically drained at the end of the day,” a former custody officer at the US Penitentiary, Thomson, facility in the northwestern region of Illinois, said. “I used to dread going to work. There were way too many inmates for the amount of stuff that’s there.”