We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
JUDGE BLOCKS BOP TRANSGENDER ORDER FOR NOW
The Supreme Court yesterday handed down three cases of interest to prisoners and their families, and a District of Columbia judge laid the leather to a class action against the Federal Bureau of Prison’s handling of FSA credits. All of that must wait until the weekend for me to digest and write about. For now, I have a decision to write about from last week, in which a federal judge ruled that the BOP cannot withhold gender-transition medical care from inmates identifying as transgender.
Under an Executive Order that President Trump signed on January 20th, the BOP was ordered to withhold any accommodations – from surgery and hormone therapy to access to gender-specific underwear and other commissary items – previously provided to inmates identifying as transgender.
In a 36-page-opinion, US District Judge Royce C. Lamberth (U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia) granted a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the Executive Order and assigned class-action status to the lawsuit, brought on behalf of an estimated 1,028 BOP inmates who are diagnosed with gender dysphoria, a disorder caused by a mismatch between their assigned gender and their perceived gender. The preliminary injunction will remain in place while attorneys for the ACLU and the Transgender Law Center pursue a lawsuit challenging Trump’s executive order.
The Judge wrote that BOP rules adopted in response to the Executive Order seemed likely to be found to be “arbitrary and capricious” in violation of 5 USC § 702(6) and the 8th Amendment. The judge ordered the BOP to continue providing hormone therapy to transgender people as needed, and to restore access to social accommodations such as hair removal, chest binders and undergarments. “The BOP may not arbitrarily deprive inmates of medication or other lifestyle accommodations that its own medical staff have deemed to be medically appropriate,” he wrote.
The ACLU and the Transgender Law Center filed the suit on behalf of one trans woman and two trans men, but the judge made it a class action representing any person incarcerated in federal prison who now needs, or who may in the future need, access to gender-affirming care.
Memorandum Opinion (ECF 67), Kingdom v. Trump, Case No 1:25cv691 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 105237, (D.D.C., June 2, 2025)
Washington Post, U.S. judge halts Trump ban on treatment for 1,000 transgender prisoners (June 3, 2025)
– Thomas L. Root