We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

DOJ RELAXES PATTERN SCORE LIMITATION FOR CARES ACT HOME CONFINEMENT

Bureau of Prisons Director Michael Carvajal last Thursday told the Senate Judiciary Committee that the Dept of Justice has modified the CARES Act home confinement criteria to qualify people whose PATTERN recidivism scores are “low” for home confinement.

A memorandum apparently has been issued, because in a FAMM press release issued on Friday, FAMM president Kevin Ring said “We’re grateful that the new administration heeded the widespread calls to make more people eligible for home confinement. The original criteria were too narrow.”

Although I tried Friday and over the weekend to obtain a copy of the memo, I was not able to. The Ring statement suggests that more than one standard may have changed, but nothing else has been confirmed. I have heard a rumor as to what that change might have been, but I try not to deal in rumors, so I am awaiting confirmation.

The DOJ decision to expand CARES Act home confinement at this time suggests that the Administration does not intend to stop COVID home confinement placement anytime soon, despite the fact that all inmates will have access to vaccine within the next month. Carvajal told the Committee, “We are working to get as many people as are appropriate out within the criteria we are given.”

Sen Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) complained to Carvajal that the BOP’s use of “home confinement fails to comply with the First Step Act.”

Committee Chair Richard Durbin (D-Illinois) was even blunter, asking Carvajal whether he had been directed to make eligibility for CARES Act home confinement as restrictive as possible. He said of the 230 BOP inmate COVID deaths, “These were preventable deaths. It is clear that the Bureau has been far too rigid in approving transfers to home confinement and to approve compassionate release. This is part of a broader issue of mismanagement.”

Carvajal told the Committee that the BOP, which has about 4,500 prisoners on home confinement under the CARES Act, has always followed DOJ guidance. No one asked him about the BOP’s own gloss on those criteria, which was the April 22, 2020, BOP memo requiring 50% of the sentence to be served (a standard from which the BOP said it could deviate “in its discretion,” if, for example, your name is Paul Manafort or Chaka Fattah).

Carvajal said the home confinement program has been a success. Right now, over 4,500 inmates are at home under the CARES Act, while only 151 have been returned to prison, 26 of which for escape from monitoring, and only three for new crimes (only one of which was violent).

Many Committee members expressed dismay at the January 15 DOJ Office of Legal Counsel opinion that CARES Act confinees have to return to prison when the pandemic ends. Carvajal said about 2,400 of the CARES Act confinees have more than a year left on their sentences, and about 310 of those have more than five years to do. He said the BOP just wants guidance: “I ask that the statute be changed, or that we work with the DOJ… I don’t want somebody to believe that the Bureau of Prisons somehow doesn’t want to let someone out.”

But if the confinees are sent back, Carvajal said the BOP is prepared to handle the influx. Not everyone agrees. “We don’t have the staff,” Council of Prison Locals Southeast Regional Vice President Joe Rojas told Reuters. “We are already in chaos as it is, as an agency.”

Durbin and Grassley said they would ask the new Attorney General to withdraw the January OLJ memorandum, or – if that failed – they would seek to change the statute.

Courthouse News Service, Federal Prisons Flunked the Pandemic, Senators Say (April 15, 2021)

Reuters, U.S. has no plans to order inmates released in pandemic back to prison-official (April 15, 2021)

Reason, Pressure Grows on Biden To Rescind Memo That Would Send Thousands Released on Home Confinement Back to Federal Prison (April 16, 2021)

FAMM, FAMM releases statement on Department of Justice expanding home confinement (April 16, 2021)

Senate Judiciary Committee, Oversight of the Bureau of Prisons (April 15, 2021)

– Thomas L. Root