We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.
FIRST STEP REPORT ISSUED
The First Step Act required that starting in 2020, the Attorney General generate an annual report on the Bureau of Prisons’ implementation of the various provisions of the law. The AG issued the report two weeks ago, which reads more like a hagiography of First Step compliance than a dispassionate recitation of how rocky the road to First Step implementation has been.
Example: The AG says the BOP and Department of Justice “also implemented and responded to changes the FSA made involving retroactive application of the Fair Sentencing Act, compassionate release, and good conduct time.” If “implemented and responded to changes” means fighting compassionate release (10,929 out of 10,940 requests to the BOP for compassionate release denied) and Fair Sentencing Act reduction motions hammer-and-tong, DOJ and BOP have surely overperformed.
Surprisingly (or maybe not, given the political roar coming from Washington over the last two months), the First Step Report seems to have landed silently. Yet there are some interesting gold nuggets in the 59 pages of dross. I’m still reading it, and I’ll report more on it next week, but a few stats have jumped out already:
• 70% of all BOP inmates are designated to facilities within 500 miles of their release residences (but the Report does not compare this to the stats prior to passage of First Step);
• the BOP has transferred over 19,000 people to home confinement since last March;
• in 2020, one out of every four BOP inmates did not get any halfway house or home confinement prior to release
The most interesting tables I have seen so far are the recidivism tables. The Report found recidivism among people released under the First Step Act to be 11.3%, much less than the one-third or higher numbers usually cited. One curious finding: people who served less than 5 years had a recidivism rate of 10.9%; those serving between 5 and 10 years, 12.6%; those serving between 10 and 15 years, 13.1%; and those serving over 15 years, 7.8%.
These stats present a strong argument about the deterrence value (or lack thereof) of sentences, a point which should be part of any 18 USC § 3553(a) analysis in a compassionate release or Fair Sentencing Act determination.
Dept of Justice, The Attorney General’s First Step Act Section 3634 Annual Report (December 21, 2020)
– Thomas L. Root