We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

WISDOM OF THE ANCIENTS

At age 92, Senior Judge Jack Weinstein is not only still on the Eastern District of New York federal bench, but he remains one of the most industrious and thoughtful federal judges in America, a jurist prone to issuing detailed and resource-rich decision.

In a 15-page opinion hand down last week, Judge Weinstein released Cheyenne Simons under the retroactive Fair Sentencing Act after Chey had served 11 years of his 12-year sentence. This does not sound like such a big deal (a 9% discount on the original immurement), except that as a Guidelines career offender with 50 grams of crack, Cheyenne had faced a 262-month minimum Guidelines advisory sentencing range term in 2008, when Judge Weinstein sentenced him to 144 months instead. What’s more, because of a quirk in how EDNY was applying 18 USC 924(c)’s mandatory consecutive sentence (for using a gun in a drug trafficking crime) back then – a quirk since remedied by the Supreme Court in Abbott v. United States –  Chey did not get a 5-year mandatory consecutive sentence for the gun charge then. Unfortunately, he was obligated to get it now.

Cheyenne had pled to 50 grams of crack, but at the 2008 sentencing, the court attributed over 500 grams of crack to him for Guidelines sentencing purposes. The government argued that under the FSA resentencing, the 500 grams made him subject to the new 280-gram 10-year minimum. Judge Weinstein refused:

Any argument that Simons is ineligible for relief on the basis that his actual conduct involved distribution of 280 grams or more of cocaine base, triggering the 841(b)(1)(A) penalties and a 10-year minimum term of imprisonment, is unsound. Statutory penalties are determined by facts submitted to a grand jury, a trial jury, or established by a guilty plea. Findings by a judge… may be used to determine a sentence within the statutory penalties, but do not establish statutory penalties and cannot change the mandatory minimum sentence now applicable.

Although the 924(c) penalty left Chey’s Guidelines at 262-327 months, Judge Weinstein held that the retroactive FSA gave him the discretionary authority to reduce the sentence. Because Chey had “taken substantial steps during his period of incarceration to achieve the rehabilitative goals sought by the original sentence imposed,” Judge Weinstein set him free.

United States v. Simons, 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 67964 (EDNY, Apr. 22, 2019)

– Thomas L. Root